do not tell a lie
He had to give it back and apologize to the Director of Recreation.
he was playing with the apple with asher
In "The Giver," Jonas's father breaks the rule against taking home a baby from the Nurturing Center when he brings home Gabriel, a child who is not thriving. This action surprises Jonas because it reveals his father's deep compassion and willingness to care for Gabriel, despite the strict regulations of their community. It also highlights the emotional connections that can exist even within a highly controlled society.
He is required to until he gets assigned to be the reciever. Then he is exempt from that rule.
What does Jonas think of EACH RULE he receives in chapter 9?
Jonas breaks the rule and takes Gabriel to the home of the Giver because he believes that Gabriel is in danger of being released from the community due to his inability to sleep through the night. The Giver offers to take care of Gabriel and protect him from being released. Jonas's decision reflects his growing awareness of the flaws in the community and his desire to protect those he cares about.
The rule that bothered Jonas the most during his training in "The Giver" was the rule that he could not share his training experiences or feelings with anyone else, not even his family. This isolation and inability to communicate with others made him feel lonely and detached from those around him.
In the book "The Giver," Father breaks the rule of releasing a twin, Jonas's new sibling, because he mistakenly believes the child is too small and frail to thrive. This action goes against the rules of the community and demonstrates Father's compassion and humanity.
Jonas' mother in "The Giver" is depicted as caring, obedient to authority, and emotionally distant due to the lack of memories and emotions in the society. She is also portrayed as a rule-follower and supporter of the community's strict regulations.
Jonas initially views the rules in the community as necessary for maintaining order and safety. However, as he learns more about the restrictions in the community and the impact they have on individual freedoms and emotions, his perspective on the rules begins to shift. He starts to question their purpose and sees them as limiting rather than protective.
Jonas's father determined which new child would be released based on a set of criteria provided by the society. The decision was ultimately made by a group of Elders or a committee who examined factors such as health, development, and compatibility with the community. The final decision was then approved by the Chief Elder.
The fact that his father had broken the rule of looking at the naming sheet before the naming ceremony