What would you like to do?

Has a US Supreme Court justice ever resigned?

already exists.

Would you like to merge this question into it?

already exists as an alternate of this question.

Would you like to make it the primary and merge this question into it?

exists and is an alternate of .

Yes. Sixteen justices have resigned from the Court since it was established in 1789. In the early years, the most common reason for resignation was the rigorous circuit riding schedule that forced the justices to travel long distances, on horseback or by carriage, most of the year. John Jay, the first Chief Justice, resigned after being elected Governor of New York. After Congress passed the Judiciary Act of 1869 that had a provision for retirement pay, more justices retired than resigned. Still, other justices continued to leave the Court due to illness, dislike of the work, or conflicts of interest.

The following list shows which justices resigned in order of appointment, and includes the years served as well as the appointing President.

1.........John Jay, (CJ)..................1789 - 1795........Washington
4.........John Blair, Jr....................1790 - 1795........Washington
5.........John Rutledge..................1790 - 1791........Washington
7.........Thomas Johnson..............1792 - 1793........Washington
32.......Benjamin R. Curtis............1857 - 1857........Filmore
33.......John Archibald Campbell....1853 - 1861........Pierce
37........David David....................1862 - 1877........Lincoln
62.......Charles Evans Hughes.......1910 - 1916........Taft
65.......Mahlon Pitney...................1912 - 1922........Taft
68.......John Hessein Clark............1916 - 1922........Wilson
69.......William H. Taft (CJ)...........1921 - 1930.........Harding
74.......Owen Roberts...................1930 - 1945........Hoover
81.......James F. Byrnes................1941 - 1942........Roosevelt
91.......Charles Evans Whittaker.....1957 - 1962.........Eisenhower
94.......Arthur Goldburg................1962 - 1965.........Kennedy
95........Abe Fortas.......................1965 - 1969.........Johnson
2 people found this useful
Thanks for the feedback!

Were there ever thirteen US Supreme Court Justices?

  No, but the number has varied over the years, because the Constitution does not say there has to be 9 members. The Supreme Court began with 6, then went to 5, then to 7,

What happens if a US Supreme Court justice retires resigns or dies?

The President of the United States nominates someone to fill his or her vacancy; the Senate Judiciary Committee conducts a hearing; and the full Senate votes on whether to con

What do US Supreme Court Justices do?

The Justices of the U.S. Supreme Court interpret the law. When we say "the Court" (meaning the U.S. Supreme Court), we mean the Justices of the Supreme Court. The Court (the J

Has there ever been a foreign-born US Supreme Court Justice?

Yes. Six Supreme Court justices were born outside the United States (or Colonial America, in some cases):     James Wilson (1789-1798), Caskardy, Scotland  James Ire

What is a US Supreme Court justice?

The US Supreme Court is the highest appellate court in the United States for cases involving federal law and constitutional issues. It is also considered the head of the Judic

Has a US Supreme Court justice ever been impeached?

Yes. Justice Samuel Chase was impeached by the House of Representatives in 1804, but was acquitted at his Senate trial in early 1805. Chase is the only US Supreme Court justic

Has any US Supreme Court Justice ever been elected President of the US?

William Howard Taft was elected President in 1908, and served a single term in the White House, from 1909-1913. He was later appointed Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, whic

Did Justice Tom Clark die or resign from the Supreme Court?

President Harry Truman appointed Tom C. Clark to the US Supreme Court in 1949 to replace Justice Frank Murphy, who died in office. Justice Clark served for 28 years, and retir

Why are there justices on the US Supreme Court?

"Justice" is just a high-falutin' term for "judge." In the early days of the Court, there was a desire to establish the significance of the federal judiciary. And let's face i

Has a US Supreme Court justice ever recused himself from a case?

Yes. US Supreme Court justices have recused themselves from cases many times across the history of the Court. Judges, justices and magistrates are required (or encouraged) u

What US Supreme Court justice resigned in protest of the Dred Scott decision?

Benjamin R. Curtis, one of two dissenters in the Dred Scott decision, resigned from the US Supreme Court on September 30, 1857, as a direct result of his disagreement with the
In Slavery

What US Supreme Court justice resigned in disgust over the majority opinion of a case?

Benjamin R. Curtis, one of the two justices who dissented from the majority in Dred Scott v. Sanford, (1857) resigned from the US Supreme Court because of the outcome of that