How does Jane White's Quarry compare with William Golding's Lord of the Flies?

Answer 1

Both of the following quote come from 'the neglected book page' website.

Peter Brooke, who directed the 1963 movie version of Lord of the Flies said...
It's a British novel from 1960s about three adolescent boys who kidnap a boy and keep him in a cave in a quarry. It's been compared to Lord of the Flies. It got great reviews when it came out. I've just finished it and thought it was extremely well done. But a real enigma. I can't figure out what it is really about except perhaps the breakdown of society.

Richard Freeman, in the Saturday Review...
… is an allegory with a variety of more or less cosmic overtones. The action takes place not in a normal, pastoral English summer, but in an arid wasteland during a fierce heat wave. Images of darkness and light are strewn about and the cave is philosophically associated with the one in Plato's Republic. The victim, especially, is given much symbolic weight to bear as a universal scapegoat…. Ultimately, the book is about the complex symbiosis between prosecutor and prey. If Quarry is less richly imagined than Lord of the Flies and lacks its verbal distinction, it is nevertheless an extraordinarily assured first novel, and is even superior to Golding's in its control of allegory, the bare bones of which are less frequently allowed to obtrude.