How does the ban on same-sex marriage violate the 14th amendment to the US Constitution?

already exists.

Would you like to merge this question into it?

already exists as an alternate of this question.

Would you like to make it the primary and merge this question into it?

exists and is an alternate of .

The 14th Amendment has two applicable parts: The Due Process Clause and the Equal Protection Clause.

Under the Due Process Clause, no state can deprive its citizens of life, liberty or property (which has been interpreted to include rights and freedoms) without due process of law. This means states cannot deprive their citizens of rights contained in, guaranteed by or extending from the U.S. Constitution.

Although the US Constitution does not mention marriage in any way, it does contain a "Full Faith and Credit Clause" which requires state A to honor contracts made in state B. This is also applied to things such as license plates, legal name changes, car registrations, divorces, adoptions and marriages.
The 1996 Defense of Marriage Act ("DOMA") purports to enable states to violate the Full Faith and Credit Clause with respect to marriage, based upon the gender of the parties thereto. One can argue that the Due Process Clause prohibits states from violating the Full Faith and Credit Clause without judicial review.

Under the Equal Protection Clause, a state must provide equal protection under the law to all persons within its jurisdiction. This means that if a state enacts a law that has an adverse impact on one group of people, it may not do so arbitrarily and there must exist a compelling need for the law to be enacted.

As evidenced by California's Proposition 8 trials, it can be difficult to come up with a legal argument against same-sex marriage without relying upon religious doctrine which is inadmissible. This is one reason why the parties who sued to prevent same-sex marriage in California also fought very hard to prevent videotape of them speaking the arguments they made in court from being released to the public. They themselves argued that if the public saw them saying the things they said in Court, there would be outrage, death threats and their careers would be irreparably harmed.

One can argue that the Equal Protection Clause is violated by states that permit some citizens to marry, but not others and then cannot produce a coherent argument as to why this is necessary.
7 people found this useful

How can states amend their constitutions to ban same-sex marriage when Article IV of the US Constitution states that public acts such as marriages from one state are legal in all states?

The "full faith and credit" clause of Article IV of the US constitution forces states to recognize the public acts and records of other states.. However, there is a phrase in Article IV that allows congress to regulate this. In 1996 congress exercised this power by passing the Defense of Marriage A (MORE)

What did the 14th amendment ban?

it gave the freed man supposed civil rights... the 15th amendment did the rest\n. \n"no state shall make or enforce any law that shall abridge the privileges of a citizen of the United States..."

What does the Ninth Amendment to the US Constitution have to do with same-sex marriage?

Ninth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution reads:. The enumeration in the Constitution, of certain rights, shall not be construed to deny or disparage others retained by the people. . The ninth amendment implies that if the right to gay marriage is not mentioned in the constitution, that does not (MORE)

Which Constitutional amendment pertains to same-sex marriage in California?

Proposition 8 amended the state constitution of California to eliminate the right of same-sex couples to marry. Article I. Section 7.5 was added to the California Constitution, to read:. Sec. 7.5. Only marriage between a man and a woman is valid or recognized in California.. This constitutional am (MORE)

How does segregation in schools violate the 14th amendment?

The 14th amendment was created during the Reconstruction Era of theUnited States. The amendment was meant to protect US citizenshiprights as well as enforce equal protection of laws. By nature,segregation of race in schools violated this amendment.

Why do some people favor an amendment to the US Constitution banning same-sex marriage?

I believe that people are afraid of what they do not understand. . In general, opposition to same-sex marriage comes down to two issues: . Certain religions are against homosexuality (they consider it a sin), and thus, allowing a sinner to take part in a holy sacrament violates their religiou (MORE)

Who opposes a constitutional amendment to ban same-sex marriage supports civil unions and says states should decide about marriage?

This is the position of many Democratic legislators on both the state and federal levels in the United States. It is a moderate position that is slowly losing popularity as more and more public officials move towards the progressive end of the spectrum, after realizing that the only purpose of creat (MORE)

Why do some people oppose an amendment to the US Constitution that would make flag burning or same-sex marriage illegal?

While these are two different issues entirely, the underlying principle for rejecting them is very similar. The United States has generally moved towards greater individual freedom and inclusion of all peoples - banning flag burning and same-sex marriage would by necessity reduce the freedom of peop (MORE)

How many states have constitutional amendments banning same-sex marriage?

Alabama (by constitution and statute); . Arizona (by constitution and statute); . Arkansas (by constitution and statute); . Florida (by constitution and statute); . Georgia (by constitution and statute); . Kansas (by constitution and statute); . Kentucky (by constitution and statute); . Louis (MORE)

Which US states have banned same-sex marriage by statute?

Alabama (by constitution and statute); . Alaska (by constitution and statute); . Arizona (by constitution and statute); . Arkansas (by constitution and statute); . Colorado (by constitution and statute); . Florida (by constitution and statute); . Georgia (by constitution and statute); . Idaho (MORE)

How do gays feel about the Constitutional amendment to ban same-sex marriage?

Answering for myself (I'm gay and -- thanks to the State of Iowa -- married to my husband): 1. Just to be absolutely clear: this is about civil marriage, not the religious sacrament. Civil marriage is a partnership contract and -- like any other contract -- should be available to any two consenting (MORE)

Why was the 14th amendment added to the US Constitution?

The 14th amendment is part of the "civil war" amendments providing for the rights of citizenship, voting for former slaves. It also states that "no state shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any state deprive any p (MORE)

Which amendment to the US Constitution is violated by banning same-sex marriage?

No existing amendment to the US Constitution explicitly protects orbans same-sex marriage. There is currently no nationwide ban on same-sex marriage in theUnited States and the issue is left up to the individual states.However, the federal government was prohibited from recognizingsuch marriages, e (MORE)

What constitutional amendment banned slavery?

The Thirteenth Amendment, which was passed in 1865. The Emancipation Proclamation which went into effect on January 1, 1863, only outlawed slavery in states that were engaged in rebellion against the Union government. Thus before the adoption of this amendment, slavery continued to be legal in slav (MORE)

How can the government violate or break the Amendment X to the US Constitution?

The same way anybody can break any law: illegally. If you're alleging that this has occurred and you want to know why it was allowed in a particular instance that you consider to be a violation, you'll have to be more specific. However, there are two basic ways the federal government could just (MORE)

What is the amdendment to the US Constitution that President Bush used to ban same-sex marriage?

President Bush did not ban gay marriage. However, under his administration the Federal Marriage Amendment (FMA) was proposed and defeated. It would have limited marriage in the United States to only be between one man and one woman. Also, Republicans are not purely to blame for the federal govern (MORE)

Is banning same-sex marriage a violation of human rights?

Yes. Marriage is a right. It is a right applicable to humans. Same-sex couples are humans. Same-sex couples have human rights. Some governments do not permit same-sex couples to marry. Those governments are violating the human rights of same-sex couples.

Should the US Constitution be amended to permit same-sex marriage?

This does not necessarily have to occur. The constitutions does not define individual rights outside of the Bill of Rights, and it does not address marriage at all; the Defense of Marriage Act does that ( DOMA: Public Law 104-199, 110 Stat. 2419, signed into law by President Bill Clinton on Septem (MORE)

Is an American Indian tribe prohibited from performing same-sex marriages if their tribal land is located in a state where such marriages have been banned by statute or constitutional amendment?

No. All federally recognized native American Indian tribes in the United States are considered sovereign nations. State and federal laws and constitutions do not apply to members of the tribe while they are physically present on tribal lands. Therefore, tribes are free to legalize or ban same-sex ma (MORE)

What section in the UN human rights document does the banning of same-sex marriage violate?

Article 16 says: "Men and women of full age, without any limitation due to race, nationality or religion, have the right to marry". Article 2 says: "Everyone is entitled to all the rights and freedoms set forth in this Declaration, without distinction of any kind, such as race, colour, sex, langu (MORE)

How many US state constitutions ban same-sex marriage?

Alabama . Alaska . Arizona . Arkansas . Colorado . Florida . Georgia . Idaho . Kansas . Kentucky . Louisiana . Michigan . Mississippi . Missouri . Montana . Nebraska . Nevada . North Carolina . North Dakota . Ohio . Oklahoma . Oregon . South Carolina . Tenn (MORE)

Is a same-sex marriage amendment constitutional?

This is a complex legal question that even experts are not able to answer with certainty. However, based upon court decisions to date and legal opinions that I have read, a constitutional amendment to ban same-sex marriage is likely to be found constitutional in jurisdictions where same-sex couples (MORE)

What amendment to the us constitution did the country unit system violate?

The County Unit System in Georgia works similarly to theelectoral college on the national level. Nonetheless, it violatesthe principle of "one person - one vote" endorsed by Earl Warren,the Chief Justice who delivered the rendering of Baker v. Carr,which was topically similar to Gray v. Sanders. N (MORE)