The Ninety-Five Theses

The Ninety Five Theses

Latin Wikisource has original text related to this article: Disputatio pro declaratione virtutis indulgentiarum

Wikisource has original text related to this article: 95 Theses

The Ninety-Five Theses on the Power and Efficacy of Indulgences (Latin: Disputatio pro declaratione virtutis indulgentiarum), commonly known as The Ninety-Five Theses, were written by Martin Luther in 1517 and are widely regarded as the primary catalyst for the Protestant Reformation. Luther used these theses to display his displeasure with some of the Roman Catholic clergy's abuses, most notably the sale of indulgences; this ultimately gave birth to Protestantism. Luther's popularity encouraged others to share their doubts about Catholicism.

Background

Protestant Reformation

Precursors Waldensians (I 12th century) Avignon Papacy (1309 to 1377) John Wycliffe (E, 1320–1384) Western Schism (1378–1417) Jan Hus (B, ~1369–1415) Hussite Wars (1420 to ~1434) Northern Renaissance German mysticism The Start of the Reformation English Reformation The Ninety-Five Theses Peasants' War Schmalkaldic League Magisterial · Radical · Counter Protestant Reformers Martin Luther Philipp Melanchthon Thomas Müntzer Menno Simons Martin Bucer Olaus & Laurentius Petri Huldrych Zwingli John Calvin John Knox Reformation by location Denmark · England · Finland Germany · Iceland · Italy Netherlands · Norway · Scotland Sweden · France · Switzerland

This box: view • talk • edit

The background to Luther's Ninety-Five Theses centers on particular disputes within the Catholic Church regarding confession and absolution. Significantly, the Theses offer a view on the validity of indulgences (remissions of temporal punishment due for sins which have already been forgiven). They also view with great cynicism the practice of indulgences being sold, and thus the penance for sin representing a financial transaction rather than genuine contrition. Luther's theses argued that the sale of indulgences was a gross violation of the original intention of confession and penance, and that Christians were being falsely told that they could find absolution through the purchase of indulgences.

The Castle Church in Wittenberg, Germany, in the Holy Roman Empire, where the Ninety-five Theses famously appeared, held one of Europe's largest collections of religious artifacts, or holy relics. These had been piously collected by Frederick III of Saxony. At that time pious veneration, or viewing, of relics was purported to allow the viewer to receive relief from temporal punishment for sins in purgatory. By 1509 Frederick had over 5,000 relics, purportedly "including vials of the milk of the Virgin Mary, straw from the manger [of Jesus], and the body of one of the innocents massacred by King Herod."^[1]

As part of a fund-raising campaign commissioned by Pope Leo X to finance the renovation of St. Peter's Basilica in Rome, Johann Tetzel, a Dominican priest, began the selling of indulgences in the German lands. Albert of Mainz (the Archbishop of Mainz) in Germany had borrowed heavily to pay for his high church rank and was deeply in debt. He agreed to allow the sale of the indulgences in his territory in exchange for a cut of the proceeds. Luther was apparently not aware of this. Even though Luther's prince, Frederick III, and the prince of the neighboring territory, George, Duke of Saxony, forbade the sale in their lands, Luther's parishioners traveled to purchase them. When these people came to confession, they presented their plenary indulgences which they had paid good silver money for, claiming they no longer had to repent of their sins, since the document promised to forgive all their sins. Luther was outraged that they had paid money for what was theirs by right as a free gift from God. He felt compelled to expose the fraud that was being sold to the pious people. This exposure was to take place in the form of a public scholarly debate at the University of Wittenberg. The Ninety-five Theses outlined the items to be discussed and issued the challenge to any and all comers. The 95 theses were written into a book.

Initial dissemination

A replica of the Ninety-five Theses in Schlosskirche, Wittenberg

According to a report written by Philipp Melanchthon, Luther posted the Ninety-Five Theses at the Castle Church in Wittenberg, Germany on October 31, 1517. Some scholars have questioned the accuracy of this account, noting that no contemporaneous evidence exists for it.^[2] Others have countered that no such evidence is necessary, because this action was the customary way of advertising an event on a university campus.^[3] Church doors at the time functioned very much as bulletin boards. Still others suggest the posting may well have happened sometime in November 1517. When referring to the 95 Theses, it is nevertheless quite safe to say that they were posted on October 31, 1517, on a church door. The day of October 31 is All Hallow's Eve, and, since on the following day (All Saints) most people will go to church, posting his theses on this day makes sense.^[4]

Most recently, in February 2007, the media reported that a handwritten note by Luther's secretary Georg Rörer, found in the university library at Jena, appeared to confirm the traditional account of Luther's nailing the theses to the door.^[5] As of February 2007^[update], this new find has yet to be assessed by scholars.^[6]

Reaction to the Ninety-Five Theses

Part of a series on the History of Christian Theology
Background
Four Marks of the Church Early Christianity · Timeline History of Christianity Theology · Ecclesiastical polity Trinitarianism · Nontrinitarianism Christology · Mariology Biblical Canon: Deuterocanonical and Apocryphal books
Creeds
Apostles' Creed · Nicene Creed Chalcedonian · Athanasian
Patristic theology & Councils
Church Fathers · Augustine Nicaea · Chalcedon · Ephesus
Post-Nicene development
Heresy · List of heresies Monophysitism · Monothelitism Iconoclasm · Gregory I · Alcuin Photios · East-West Schism Scholasticism · Aquinas · Anselm William of Ockham Gregory Palamas · Old Believers
Reformation
Protestant Reformation Luther · Melanchthon Indulgences · Justification Sola fide · 95 Theses Book of Concord Predestination · John Calvin Arminianism · English Reformation Counter-Reformation · Trent
Since the Reformation
Pietism · Revivalism John Wesley · Great Awakenings Holiness movement Restorationism · Existentialism Liberalism and Postmodernism Vatican II · Radical orthodoxy Jean-Luc Marion · Hermeneutics Deconstruction-and-religion Liberation Theology · Christian Anarchism
Christianity Portal
This box: view • talk • edit

According to some, the Ninety-Five Theses gained enormous popularity over a very short period of time. Luther's ideas resonated with people regardless of class, status, or wealth, at a time when such concepts were crucial to the social order.^[7]

On June 15, 1520, Pope Leo X issued a rebuttal to Luther's 95 Theses, a papal encyclical entitled Exsurge Domine. This document outlined the Magisterium of the Catholic Church's findings of where Luther had erred. The remarkable quality of this document (and Luther's) is that most of the arguments back and forth are nearly immaterial to the present theological discussion. Much of the back-and-forth includes little understood concepts such as purgatory, personal understanding of contrition, and the sanctification of souls after death. Indeed, they are both a misconstruction of current doctrine, carefully refined to that circumstance. The one baits the other—a strategy that fails to address the fundamental issue, which might be stated as "the over-objectification (papal) versus the over-subjectification of Christianity (Lutheran)."^{[citation needed]}

Some of the more understood theological concepts which Luther raised still divide the Christian Church today. These questions plagued Luther, who often resorted to mortification of the flesh so as to attempt to be perfectly contrite before God. Erasmus counseled Luther to wait until scholarship was sufficient to permit reform to be more accurate than a total dependence on the Bible^{[citation needed]}, which generated Anabaptism, Protestantism, and, in the modern era, evangelicalism. Meanwhile, Luther's Theses became a declaration of independence in Northern Europe, around which rallied enormous social changes, like the decline of feudalism, the rise of commercialism, and the discovery of the Western Hemisphere.^[8]

As early as October 27, 1521, the chapel at Wittenberg suppressed private Masses. In 1522, much of the city began celebrating Lutheran services instead of Roman Catholic. Luther's popularity grew rapidly, mostly due to the general Roman Catholic church member's dissatisfaction with the corruption and "worldly" desires and habits of the Roman Curia. Thus began the great Protestant Reformation that spurred on the more than 30,000 Christian denominations throughout the world of today.^[9][10][11]

References

Bibliography

• Erwin Iserloh The Theses Were Not Posted: Luther Between Reform and Reformation. trans. by Jared Wicks, S.J.. Boston: Beacon Press, 1968.
• Palmer, R.R. A History of the Modern World. New York: McGraw Hill, 2002

External links

• Full Latin Text: 95 Theses by Dr. Martin Luther (1517)
• Full English Text: 95 Theses
• BELIEVE Religious Information Source

v • d • e Martin Luther Works A Mighty Fortress Is Our God · On War against the Turk · Large Catechism · Luther Bible · On the Bondage of the Will · On the Freedom of a Christian · On the Jews and Their Lies · Vom Schem Hamphoras · Smalcald Articles · Small Catechism · The Adoration of the Sacrament · Theology of the Cross · The Ninety-Five Theses · To the Christian Nobility of the German Nation · Confession Concerning Christ's Supper · Formula missae · Deutsche Messe Topics Augsburg Confession · Decet Romanum Pontificem · Diet of Worms · Exsurge Domine · Lutheranism · Luther rose · Sacramental union · Martin Luther's views on Mary · Antisemitism · Words of Institution People Albert of Mainz · Bartholomaeus Arnoldi · Desiderius Erasmus · Georg Rörer · Johann Cochlaeus · Johann von Staupitz · Justus Jonas · Hans and Margarethe Luther · Karl von Miltitz · Katharina von Bora · Philipp Melanchthon