Can you give a poem to a girl in your class who is a Jehovah's Witness instead of a Christmas gift?

Answer 1

Giving A Poem

Of course why not, would you give her a gift in any other day if you felt like giving it to her then why not then. My husbands nephews daughter's first birthday came around and I called her to say how happy I was that we have had the privilege of have her presence on this earth for a year. They did not get offended and they are Jehovahs Witness. It's how you give the present or how you express yourself. Give her the poem like you would give it to her if it was any other day. Don't obviouly say happy Christmas just say I want to give you this poem because I think it's nice and make sure then that the poem doesn't have anything to do with Christmas that's important don't forget. The trick is the "approach". Always be respectful and nice and you'll go a long way.

No do not attempt to give them any gift of any form on Christmas.

Absolutly but if it is sopossed to be a Christmas gift than we would politly not except it.

Yes, but if you like her more than friends, your only choice is to become a JW, because they believe that associating with anyone out of "The Truth" should be minimized and if any relationships progress it is considered a sin, Also, if the poem is meant to be a Christmas gift it would be best to not, as her parents might get too snoopy, or she may deny it as said before.

Answer 2

Yes, you can write a heartfelt poem that conveys your appreciation and well wishes for the holidays without directly mentioning Christmas. Focus on themes of friendship, warmth, and kindness that are universal and not tied to any specific holiday. Acknowledge and respect her religious beliefs by avoiding any references to Christmas and instead emphasize the spirit of giving and love.