Is it theft if somebody won't return something?

Answer 1

In the case of a criminal theft - if you reported the theft to law enforcement - even though the property was later returned, it is not, strictly speaking, up to YOU, as to whether to press charges or not. It is law enforcement and the prosecutors office that makes that determination.

Answer 2

If someone refuses to return something that does not belong to them, it could potentially be considered theft, especially if they have the intention of permanently depriving the owner of their rightful possession. It would depend on the specific circumstances and laws of the jurisdiction.

Answer 3

Yes. The decision to charge theft, in most cases, is up to the individual who suffered the loss (the victim). If they decide not to prosecute because you returned the item, count yourself lucky and don't ever steal anything again. In many cases, though, victims are angry at the perpetrator and want to see justice served. In these cases, even though you returned the stolen item, you will likely serve jail time and/or pay a large fine. The thinking behind this is that the item was never yours to possess and you willfully denied the owner of the item access to it. Returning it changes nothing with regard to the time you had it. Best policy - don't steal people's things.

Answer 4

No, because you have already committed the act.

But, if you give back the goods to the owner personally, then there will be no use for calling on to court.

Remember, the situation depends on what type of character the owner has.

If you give the goods back after you have been brought to the police, then you will be brought to court.

Answer 5

It is if it doesn't belong or did belong to a store. And or if you took something from a friend or relative and didn't give it back.

Answer 6

If they were stolen in the first place, yes. If you returned them voluntarily, this may affect the sentencing severity.