0
Do any details suggest that montresor might have imagined the thousand injuries and the insult or even the whole story?
Wiki User
∙ 14y ago
Certainly the simple fact that Montresor relates no details of the insults leads one to believe that he has imagined them. Also, at the carnival, Fortunato greets Montresor in a very friendly manner, willingly offers to leave it to help Montresor test the wine and insists on going through the passageway despite the dank and dark conditions. These are not the actions of a person who has insulted and injured Montresor a thousand times as Montresor believes, even though Fortunato is partially driven to do so by his vanity.
Wiki User
∙ 14y ago
Anonymous
Montresor's behavior and obsession with revenge suggest that he may have exaggerated or imagined the injuries and insult he claimed to have suffered. His meticulous planning and enjoyment of the act, along with the fact that he narrates the story many years later with vivid detail, hint at a possible fabrication to justify his actions.
Add your answer:
Earn +20 pts
Do any details suggest that montresor might have imagined the thousand injuries and the insult - or even the whole story?
Certainly the simple fact that Montresor relates no details of the insults leads one to believe that he has imagined them. Also, at the carnival, Fortunato greets Montresor in a very friendly manner, willingly offers to leave it to help Montresor test the wine and insists on going through the passageway despite the dank and dark conditions. These are not the actions of a person who has insulted and injured Montresor a thousand times as Montresor believes, even though Fortunato is partially driven to do so by his vanity.
Why does Montresor want revenge in The Cask of Amontillado?
According to Montresor's opening comments he has suffered a thousand injuries at the hands of Fortunato but now Fortunato has also insulted him. However, it is not clear if these injuries and insults are real or imagined. He gives no details and later Fortunato greets him in a very friendly way, offers to leave the carnival to test the wine for Montressor and insists on continuing through the passageway in the cellar. Although Fortunato is partly driven by his own pride and vanity, these are hardly the actions of a person who has committed a thousand injuries and insults against Montressor.
What hints does the story provide as to the thousand injuries that fortunato has inflicted on montresor?
The story mentions that Fortunato frequently insults Montresor, causing him to feel humiliated and seek revenge. Additionally, Fortunato's betrayal and disrespect towards Montresor may have contributed to the deep-seated grudge that Montresor carries against him. Overall, the story implies that Fortunato's actions of belittling and mistreating Montresor over a long period of time are the thousand injuries alluded to in the narrative.
Did Fortunato deserve his fate in 'The Cask of Amontillado'?
No. First of all the "thousand injuries" and then the insult, which Montresor claims he has suffered from Fortunato probably never even happened, because Montresor gives no details of them and Fortunato is very friendly toward Montresor throughout the story. Even if Fortunato had insulted Montresor, that would be be no reason justifying Fortunato's murder.
Which evidence best supports the claim that Montresor is insane in The Cask of Amontillado?
Montresor's meticulous and premeditated plan to lure Fortunato into the catacombs using Fortunato's weakness for wine can be seen as evidence of his insanity. Additionally, his lack of remorse or empathy for Fortunato's suffering, as evidenced by his chilling calmness throughout the murder, further supports the idea that Montresor may be mentally unstable.
Why did Montresor from 'The Cask of Amontillado' want to murder Fortunato?
No. To begin with it is likely that the thousand injuries and insults that Montresor says he has suffered from Fortunato were figments of his imagination. No details of them are given and Fortunato acts very friendly toward Montresor and has no fear of him even while deep down in the cellar. Fortunato does not act like a person who would have committed so many wrongs to Montresor. Even if Fortunato had insulted Montresor, insults are not reason to murder another person.
Why is Montresor not a dynamic character in The Cask of Amontillado?
Montresor is not a dynamic character in "The Cask of Amontillado" because he does not undergo any significant change or growth throughout the story. He remains focused on his revenge against Fortunato and does not show any inner conflicts or development in his personality or beliefs. His motivations and behavior remain constant from beginning to end.
Why does Poe not tell us the nature of the insult or describe any of the thousand injuries that the narrator suffered in the story The Cask of Amontillado?
By leaving the nature of the insult undefined, Poe creates a sense of mystery and suspense that adds to the chilling atmosphere of the story. The focus is more on the narrator's obsession with revenge rather than the specific details of the insult, emphasizing the psychological aspects of the story. This allows readers to project their own interpretations and imagine the worst possible scenario, heightening the tale's impact.
What do you think Fortunato might have done to make Montresor want such a diabolical revenge?
It is suggested in Edgar Allan Poe's story "The Cask of Amontillado" that Fortunato insulted or wronged Montresor in some way, although the specific details of the offense are not explicitly stated. This offense likely involved a significant betrayal or humiliation that fueled Montresor's desire for revenge.
Why doesn't Poe add detail about fortunato's insult?
Poe omits details in order to suggest that there are no details, which would mean that Montresor is somewhat insane for plotting a murder of someone who has done nothing to him.
Why in mythology creatures like half man and half animals were imagined?
They weren't imagined, they were created. This question makes no sense. It's like asking why you were born. They were created when a human and an animal mated ~ do I need to go into details?
Why might montresor have desides to confide in his unidentified listener?
Montresor may have confided in his unidentified listener because he wanted to boast of his crime and revel in his triumph over Fortunato. By revealing the details of his plan, he may have also been seeking validation or recognition for his cunning and deceitful actions. Additionally, sharing the story with someone allows Montresor to unburden himself of his guilt and relive the experience for his own satisfaction.
