Many people do because Erin Hunter never said that they found her body or anything. Also, on Facebook, Vicky says Hollyleaf might return. Darkscar:I think hollyleaf is alive.
That still remains a mystery. Erin Hunter has given some hint say she might be alive but know one knows for sure. I as a fan of Hollyleaf hope that she is alive and will appear in the later books.
Yes, it is confirmed in Forgotten Warrior that Hollyleaf is alive living in the tunnels. `Edit BY Bluemist Yes Hollyleaf is alive. I have read The Forgotten Warrior and it said that Dovewing and Ivypool meet Hollyleaf. She comes back to camp and explains how Ashfur died and Brambleclaw stepped in. He said that he was there and another cat killed him while Hollyleaf was pinned. She is alive!
No, but she comes back in the forgotten warrior. She disappered under the tunnels, people think she is dead but she isn't. Darkscar:i think she is alive but we don't have real proof.
*THIS REVEALS WHAT HAPPENS IN ONE OF THE BOOKS* Unfortuntely no, she dies in an underground tunnel after telling a secret she shouldn't have.
I think it will be Lionblaze. I hope not because I hate Lionblaze! I wish Lionblaze did everything Hollyleaf did and Hollyleaf was still alive to be the next leader. Lionblaze is a betrayer to his Clan! Kill Lionblaze! I like Brambleclaw. I want Brambleclaw, Graystripe, Brackenfur or Cinderheart to become leader.
No. cause she is already dead, Tippygirl105 :) She is said to be still living and is to kill Firestar but we will find out. IT WAS CONFIRMED IN ERIN HUNTER SUMMER CHAT 2011 THAT HOLLYLEAF IS ALIVE AND SHE IS THE FORGOTTEN WARRIOR! (BOOK 5 OOTS)
I think its Hollyleaf because the tunnel buries her in Sunrise and no cat had seen hide or hair of her since then, Erin Hunter has confirmed that Hollyleaf still lives.
She never did. Hollyleaf might be alive, but no one knows yet.
I Think That The Dingos Are Still Alive
Yes i think he is still alive
It depends on what you think evil is. Hollyleaf does kill Ashfur though.
Hollyleaf. She was thought to die when a tunnel colapst on her, but it has not been proved yet if she is dead. Some people think she is alive.