You never do kill him : he always escapes.
When you have the most powerful ship (Phoenix Warbird), the Shipwright and the Cannoneer, sail around the new island, Skullduggery, and the recognizable ship of Captain Crawfish will attack. If you are able to reduce his ship's "health" to zero, he sails away in defeat. Then you can return to Fort Ridley and get the shovel and treasure location.
The price is highest at Bouffant Bay, 2 to 3 times what it costs at Dragon Cove.
The sea monsters have "health meters" just like the pirate ships. If you shoot them enough times, they die and release salvage that you can collect.
On SOS Island, you have to climb up to the bridge (stairway as you enter). Talk to the captain and throw the switch that unlocks the cabin doors. You can only enter #6.
You don't. They attack your ships at random times, but more often the longer you are out of a port. You can eliminate the one at Fort Ridley by reading the governor's document and then using the broken mirror to signal the lost mariner on his raft.
You can leave any of the dreams by clicking the "wake up" banner. To complete the Binary Bard's dream, you need the Stopwatch from Captain Crawfish's dream and the Crystal Key from Black Widow's dream (second painting, upper right). When the Binary Bard uses his electric energy clock, use the Stopwatch when the time is 3:00 or 9:00, shorting out his power leads at the top, bottom, and sides. You will have to do this three times.
The answer below did not give an exact date. The answer came from Wikipedia under the heading of Prudence Island, Rhode Island. In colonial times, the island was used mainly for farming. During the American Revolution, the British forces under Captain James Wallace raided Prudence Island for livestock and engaged in a skirmish with American forces, losing approximately a dozen soldiers.
39 times
Ahab was a powerful king in biblical times, and Ahab was a captain in fiction.
The Block Island Times was created in 1970.
14598
Yes, Captain America's shield has been broken five times.
The Kent Island Bay Times was created in 1963.