Check that coin again. The last year for Indian head one cent coins was 1909.
Most likely an Indian Head cent. However, it would depend on the date, mintmark, and condition of the penny that would determine which is worth more.
The first year for a Indian Head cent is 1859
There is no such coin as a Indian Head Buckwheat penny, but a 1898 Indian Head cent in average condition is worth $1.00-$3.00
Check that date again, because there's no such thing as an 1843 Indian head cent.
No Indian Head cents were struck after 1909. A 1934 Lincoln cent is worth about 10 cents in average condition.
Most likely an Indian Head cent. However, it would depend on the date, mintmark, and condition of the penny that would determine which is worth more.
The first year for a Indian Head cent is 1859
Perhaps you mean the buffalo nickel, because Abraham Lincoln has been on the cent since 1909.
There is no such coin as a Indian Head Buckwheat penny, but a 1898 Indian Head cent in average condition is worth $1.00-$3.00
Check that date again, because there's no such thing as an 1843 Indian head cent.
No Indian Head cents were struck after 1909. A 1934 Lincoln cent is worth about 10 cents in average condition.
1895 is a common date Indian Head cent, retail values are $1.00-$5.00 for coins in average circulated condition.
The 1904 Indian Head cent is a common coin, in average condition values are $1.00-$3.00.
Indian Head cents were not produced until 1859.
Please post a new question with the coin's denomination. In 1920 Indian Head designs were used on both nickels and $10 gold pieces.
The first Indian Head cent was in 1859. Look at the date again and post new question.
Indian Head cents were minted from 1859 to 1909. If your coin is about the size of a half-dollar (around 30 mm in diameter) it is called a Large Cent or Liberty Head cent, not an Indian Head cent. If it's anything else please post a new question with more details.