There is no such coin.
Large cents were made from 1793 to 1857.
Flying eagle cents were made from 1856 to 1858.
Indian Head cents were made from 1859 to 1909.
Wheat-back Lincoln cents were made from 1909 to 1958.
Lincoln Memorial cents were made from 1959 to 2008.
Lincoln Bicentennial cents were made in 2009.
Note - where there is an overlap in dates, both designs were struck in those years.
A penny
$25 to $5,000 depending upon the condition of the coin.
No such coin exists. The US nickel would not be minted until 1866. Before that, the 5 cent coin was the silver half-dime and even then, the coin had nothing on it that bore resemblance to an American Indian. And the Indian head penny wouldn't be minted until later than 1853.
A 1883 Indian Head penny would be worth $3 if worn, $16 if none circulated.
A 1898 Indian head penny in circulated condition is worth 1 to around 23 dollars in circulated condition. These coins are not rare.
A penny
$25 to $5,000 depending upon the condition of the coin.
about $7
No such coin exists. The US nickel would not be minted until 1866. Before that, the 5 cent coin was the silver half-dime and even then, the coin had nothing on it that bore resemblance to an American Indian. And the Indian head penny wouldn't be minted until later than 1853.
$2 to $14,000
A 1883 Indian Head penny would be worth $3 if worn, $16 if none circulated.
Whatever you are willing to pay
A 1898 Indian head penny in circulated condition is worth 1 to around 23 dollars in circulated condition. These coins are not rare.
If it is a Indian penny, in good condition is worth $1.35, in fine condition is worth $2.00, in uncirculated condition is worth $30.00, proof is worth $150.00.
The first year for a Indian Head cent is 1859
Most circulated coins of this date have retail values of $18.00-$55.00 depending on the grade of the coin.
An 1800 Indian head penny is worth about $60 in good condition, $250 in fine condition, and $1,435 if it is extremely fine. Uncirculated coins are extremely rare.