Best Answer

It was! Except for the fact that the trenches surrounded towns in the Civil War. Rather than out in the middle of nowhere, in WWI. Also, you can't fire as far with Springfield Muskets.

I would like to improve the answer as follows.

During the Civil War the entrenchment systems have always left, to both attackers and defenders, an opportunity to bypass the stalemate in being represented by the two opposing entrenchments, without uniquely resorting to frontal assaults and exhausting warfare.

In other words, the army which would have "permitted" the adversary to completely surround itself into his entrenchments by maneuvering was inevitably condemned to surrender or to be destroyed. Therefore the Civil War generals of both sides had always reserved to themselves a way out, a leeway of movement, which allowed to escape and restart the match.

Bright negative example: the Vicksburg Campaign, where gen. Pemberton "allowed" Grant to get him bolt within Vicksburg entrenchments.

Bright positive example: the Overland Campaign, where both Grant an Lee were always been able to develop the opportunity to repeatedly get out from the stalemate of trench's warfare.

During the WWI, the entrenchments' network didn't allow any "leeway of maneuvering" to both of armies because it was endless covering the whole front.

Therefore both, Allied and Germans could but only to resort to a frontal assaults and exhausting warfare in order to reach their goals, so all the stuff was, no more no less, a huge and extremely costly stalemate which lasted until the year


User Avatar

Wiki User

โˆ™ 2011-05-07 20:07:58
This answer is:
User Avatar

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: How was trench warfare different in World War 1 compared to the American Civil War?
Write your answer...
Related questions

What kind of warfare did most American servicemen engage in?

trench warfare

What kind of warfare did most American servicemen enagage in?

Trench Warfare

How is trench warfare different to warfare?

Trench warfare is where soldiers lie down in narrow ditches for cover and fire their weapon from there. Warfare is just regular war.

How is trench warfare different from the war in Iraq?

Trench warfare is a defensive tactic used to protect territory you currently hold. The Iraq War is a war in Iraq, one in which Trench Warfare is being employed.

Where did the trench warfare start?

Petersburg, American Civil War ?

In which war was trench warfare first used?

Earthworks have been used in warfare back to the time of the Roman Army. It was used extensively in the American Revolution, and in the American Civil War. World War I saw trench warfare on a massive scale.

What was a solution for trench warfare?

If by "solution for trench warfare", you mean a way to end trench warfare, then the invention and widescale use of tanks, bombers and the Blitzkrieg in WWII solved trench warfare.

What was important during Trench warfare?

what were some importance of trench warfare

What are facts about trench warfare?

What are ten facts about trench warfare during WWI?

Use trench warfare in a sentence?

"Trench warfare was used in World War I"

Who won the trench warfare?

The Germans won the trench warfare ww1 in 1965

Why was trench warefare called trench warefare?

Well this one seems kind of obvious, but Trench Warfare is called Trench Warfare because the men fought in Trenches during WW1 in which trench warfare was utilized.

Trench warfare was the primary form of warfare used on which front?

Trench warfare was primary form of warfare used on western front

Who started trench warfare?

trench warfare was started by the Germans during the great war :)

What modern weapon was not used in trench warfare?

The nuclear bomb was not used in trench warfare.

Who used trench warfare?

Everyone.... ..... In ww1, trench warfare was the main thing,,, omg....

1914 Why did trench warfare develop?

the trench warfare was develped to provide a place to hind out

How did trench warfare affect soldiers in World War 1?

The trench warfare protect them

Why was trench warfare no longer effective?

Trench warfare was an extremely effective strategy because trenches were a form of defensive warfare.

What is warfare in ditches called?

Trench warfare

Who was involved in the trench warfare?

whoever was in the trench at the time

Who was involved in trench warfare?

Trench warfare was taking place during World War I. Both sides fighting in the first World War used trench warfare as a defensive tactic.

What was the style of World War 1 and World War 2?

In WW1 there was a trench warfare. In the 2nd there was a different style of warfare. Like Urban Warfare or Blitzkrieg

What was Trench warfare fought due to new?

Trench warfare was fought due to new technologies and weapons.

What was the style of warfare used in ww1?

Trench warfare