If Firestar didn't save Sandpaw from falling of the gorge, she would die. Then they will never be mates, like Spottedleaf and Firestar. If she didn't die, she would get seriously injured like Brightheart.
It's possible, as Dustpelt had feelings for Sandstorm before Firestar arrived. However, the course of their relationship would have been different without Firestar's influence on ThunderClan dynamics.
yes
But how could they be mates? They're brother and sister and in the Warriors books, the cats who are brother and sister don't mate, that I know of so far. Leafstorm
They weren't brother and sister, though many people thought they were for some reason. It even says that they aren't on the official Warriors website's Ask Erin Hunter page and the family tree page (See Related Links Below): Was Dustpelt Sandstorm's brother? It seems like they would be or Sandstorm would have probably never fallen in love with Firestar.
--Stacy (Spottedclaw from ShadowClan)
No, Dustpelt isn't Sandstorm's brother. He was very close to her when they were apprentices, and if Firestar hadn't joined the Clan they might have ended up as mates, but as time went on Sandstorm found she was more attracted to Firestar so she and Dustpelt drifted apart. Now Dustpelt is blissfully happy with Ferncloud, so I don't think he minds!
Heres what I got the impression of: Dust likes Sand. Sand likes Dust as a friend. Sand likes Fire as a friend. Dust hates Fire. Sand grows apart from Dust. Fire likes Sand. Sand likes Fire. Sand and Fire make babies. <3
(Bwhitson here) Well Sandstorm and Dustpelt are related...not brother and sister Brindleface is sandstorms mother is brindleface now dustpelt loves ferncloud is also Brindleface's kit so dustpelt loved and love two of his neices...in the wrong way..
No, they would have been mates (probility) and firestar may have been mates with spottedleaf instead of sandstorm. if it werent for firestars loylalty sandstorm would have been dustpelts mate.
Firestar chose Brackenfur as Tawnypelt's mentor because he believed that Sandstorm's loyalty to ThunderClan would be more beneficial for their clan, rather than having her train a cat from ShadowClan who may potentially be a spy. Additionally, Brackenfur had proven himself to be a strong and loyal warrior who could mentor Tawnypelt effectively.
In the "Warriors" book series, Sandstorm does not kill Firestar. Firestar dies from his injuries after a battle, not by the actions of Sandstorm. Sandstorm was Firestar's mate and a loyal friend to him throughout the series.
After Sandstorm, Firestar's second choice for mate would likely have been Spottedleaf, as they shared a close bond before her death.
NO! Firestar is awesome! In one of Firestars dreams Spottedleaf told him he should mate with Sandstorm!!!! YAY! = )
My favourites are Firestar, Sandstorm, Squirrelflight, Lionblaze, Jayfeather, Hollyleaf and Brambleclaw!Hmmm, Brambleclaw, Firestar, Graystripe, Squirrelflight, Jayfeather, Leafpool, Hollyleaf, Lionblaze, Ravenpaw, and Sandstorm are a few of mine.I like Lionblaze!all of those listed are awesome, but i like graystripe sandstorm cloudtail and ravenpaw.Well, my favorite is GrayPAW. I don't like Graystripe as much now since Silverstram died and he became so sensitive, when Graypaw was funny and cute!hmmmmmm I like Leafpool but on that list it would be Sandstorm
Yes, Spottedleaf had feelings for Firestar but it was more of a one-sided love from Spottedleaf's side as Firestar saw her more as a friend and mentor. Their relationship was complicated due to the restrictions of a romantic relationship between a medicine cat and a warrior in the ThunderClan.
This is subjective and depends on individual preferences. Some readers prefer the relationship between Firestar and Sandstorm due to their shared experiences, while others appreciate the bond between Firestar and Spottedleaf because of its tragic and spiritual aspects. Both relationships have unique qualities that appeal to different fans of the series.
I belive he did, although maybe not as much as Firestar ended up loving her. If you remember, when Sand"paw" (at the time) started to feel fond of Firepaw, Dustpelt started getting moody or grumpy, giving Firepaw sideways looks and glaring at him when she layed down beside Firepaw. "Firepaw dragged him self to his nest, barley able to stand. He colsped in his bed of leaves. His eyes wanderd for a moment. Sandpaw opened one eye and stood quietly. She stumbled carefully and layed beside Firepaw where she closed her eyes. Dustpaw glared at Firepaw, staring sadley at Sandpaw and curled himself into a ball on the cold winter night." So, i suspect he loved her, but don't feel bad. He's had plenty of healthy kits with Ferncloud! :) THEY HAD 9 I THINK
In StarClan, Firestar would likely love both Spottedleaf and Sandstorm as they were important cats in his life. However, his love for Sandstorm was stronger as she was his mate and they had a family together.
If Sandstorm were not alive, Firestar's mate may have been Spottedleaf, as they shared a close connection in the original series. However, it's important to note that this is purely speculative as the story could have taken a different direction altogether.
I think it was a good choice because when Spottedleaf died Fireheart was heart broken. He soon discovered that Sandstorm could be a good friend if she wanted to be and they grew closer and closer until they became mates and had kits. He needed a couple good friends at the time to help him through everything and discovered Sandstorm. They are also well-matched in personality as well as age. Yes I agree but also I think Sandstorm had always liked Firestar from the start but she was afraid Dustpelt would make fun of her if she was nice to Firestar . I think she started liking Firestar after he saved her life