answersLogoWhite

0


Best Answer

No. It simply means that someone thinks that there may be a different explanation. It is quite possible that the person challenging the scientific theory is wrong.

Moreover, although Einstein disproved some of Newton's theories, we continue to use them because they are accurate enough for normal circumstances and are simpler to apply.

User Avatar

Wiki User

7y ago
This answer is:
User Avatar

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: If anytime a scientific theory is challenged does it mean its not a good theory?
Write your answer...
Submit
Still have questions?
magnify glass
imp
Continue Learning about General Science

What is the scientific method good for?

For proving the theory.


How can a scientific theory be incorrect but still be considered a good scientific theory?

If all the evidence taken into consideration can be explained by the scientific model proposed and the model successfully predicts outcomes of experiments yet to be performed, it is a "good scientific theory" It still can be incorrect. If it is proven incorrect it should be abandoned.


Is it true that any hunch you have is a good as a scientific theory?

a theorem rather, it has to be proven to become an accepted theory.


Why are scientific theories said to be just a theory?

People tend to say that scientific theories are "just" a theory because of a confusion between the common usage of "theory" and the scientific definition. (In everyday speech people often use the word "theory" in the sense of a "hunch" or "vague idea". This is not what the word means in a scientific context). A scientific theory is deduced from observations and is the simplest way of describing natural phenomena. It is testable, observable, predictable, and falsifiable. Scientific theories are not the same thing as hypotheses, which are explanations that haven't been demonstrated or verified. A scientific theory has evidence to back it up. The common usage of 'theory' suggests an explanation that someone hasn't proven, or isn't able to prove. It doesn't imply evidence that has been tested; it doesn't imply predictability. When someone hears, for example, "Big Bang theory" or "the theory of evolution", they may hear the word 'theory' and associate those scientific theories with someone's opinion or suggestion. In reality, these theories are the best scientific explanations for a myriad of phenomena across multiple scientific definitions. In science, "just a theory" is a very good place to be.


Is a scientific theory subject to change?

A scientific 'theory" is science shorthand for "this is how we think it works". Sometimes the theory is developed without enough information (all the variables are e not known) and later observations and information shows the theory needs to be reworked. With enough information the theory becomes a very good model of what is happening and the changes become fewer and further apart.

Related questions

When a theory is challenged does it mean it's not a good theory?

Not necessarily. It is often through challenging it that you will find out if it is a good theory or not. Theories often need to be tested and challenged, to find out what they are like and if they are correct or not and even to be improved.


What is the scientific method good for?

For proving the theory.


How can a scientific theory be incorrect but still be considered a good scientific theory?

If all the evidence taken into consideration can be explained by the scientific model proposed and the model successfully predicts outcomes of experiments yet to be performed, it is a "good scientific theory" It still can be incorrect. If it is proven incorrect it should be abandoned.


If a scientific theory changes does this mean that it was not a good theory to begin with?

No. It means that it was the best theory supported at the time it was formulated. Theories can change if new scientific evidence provides new information.


If a scientific theory changes does that mean that it was not a good theory to begin with?

No. It means that it was the best theory supported at the time it was formulated. Theories can change if new scientific evidence provides new information.


What is your theory on evolution?

I accept the modern theory of evolution by natural selection. You can not just on a whim put forth a scientific theory. I suggest you access a good dictionary. The scientific meaning of " theory " is generally the primary meaning.


What is Abraham Maslow contribution to management theory?

Abraham Maslow's main contribution to Management Theory is in regards to motivation. His humanistic approach challenged the scientific view that money was the only way to motivate someone. He believed that each person was good-natured and just needed a personal motivator to do what needed to be done.


Is it true that any hunch you have is a good as a scientific theory?

a theorem rather, it has to be proven to become an accepted theory.


Is it true any hunch you have is a good as a scientific theory?

a theorem rather, it has to be proven to become an accepted theory.


Why are scientific theories said to be just a theory?

People tend to say that scientific theories are "just" a theory because of a confusion between the common usage of "theory" and the scientific definition. (In everyday speech people often use the word "theory" in the sense of a "hunch" or "vague idea". This is not what the word means in a scientific context). A scientific theory is deduced from observations and is the simplest way of describing natural phenomena. It is testable, observable, predictable, and falsifiable. Scientific theories are not the same thing as hypotheses, which are explanations that haven't been demonstrated or verified. A scientific theory has evidence to back it up. The common usage of 'theory' suggests an explanation that someone hasn't proven, or isn't able to prove. It doesn't imply evidence that has been tested; it doesn't imply predictability. When someone hears, for example, "Big Bang theory" or "the theory of evolution", they may hear the word 'theory' and associate those scientific theories with someone's opinion or suggestion. In reality, these theories are the best scientific explanations for a myriad of phenomena across multiple scientific definitions. In science, "just a theory" is a very good place to be.


If a scientific theory changesdoes this mean that it was not good theory to begin with?

Not necessarily... it simply means the earlier theory was based on information available at that time it was proposed. Humans are pretty good at making advances in the scientific world... experiments almost always bring new information to light - allowing us to adapt or update existing information.


Is a scientific theory subject to change?

A scientific 'theory" is science shorthand for "this is how we think it works". Sometimes the theory is developed without enough information (all the variables are e not known) and later observations and information shows the theory needs to be reworked. With enough information the theory becomes a very good model of what is happening and the changes become fewer and further apart.