In your opinion do you think the actress that is playing Bella from Twilight is good for the role?

Answer 1

Not particularly, humour was mixed in well with the seriousness of Bella and Edward's relationship in the novel, but were missed in the film as it was played with heavy weight on seriousness - the little endearing features were lost. I think Kristen Stewart is a lot to blame for this. Her portrayal of Bella was monotonous in both speech and feeling. Furthermore, although Bella was awkward, there was an air of certainty about her that made her stubborn with her feelings in the book. This feature is again lost on Kristen Stewart's portrayal. She often appears almost bored and a little too 'awkward' to truly relay Bella's passionate opinions.

A particular scene that i believe illustrates this opinion is when Bella has just finished up in the hospital room after getting checked over following her almost death by Tyler's car. Kristen and Robert discuss what she knows she has seen and he denies. In the book, Bella gets increasingly annoyed and frustrated at Edward for passing her truths off as 'seeing things' due to her head injury. Kristen does not show these emotions at all. She appears submissive to Edward and, again bored - it is quite shocking!

Answer 2

Opinions on actors' performances can vary, but Kristen Stewart's portrayal of Bella in the Twilight series received mixed reviews. Some fans appreciated her interpretation of the character's introverted and brooding nature, while others felt her performance lacked depth. Ultimately, whether she was good for the role is subjective and up to individual interpretation.