Yes you have to have 10 hearts but you also have to catch the rock lobster to marry him in on of the gull islands. I think that is after you complete Collins rainbow.
Renee will marry the male MC or Toby.
Here is the list of rival couples in Harvest Moon: Tree of Tranquility. Jin can marry Anissa Toby can marry Renee Julius can marry Candace Chase can marry Maya Calvin can marry Phoebe
you have to be in a particular date time and place these i do not no as im playing a girl and am married to toby.
if your a girl you can marry chase, wizard, luke, toby, harvest king, julius,calvin, owen, jin or gill and if your a guy you can marry selena, witch, maya, anissa, candice, kathy, luna, pheobe, renee, or harvest godess
There are more requirements to get married besides having a lot of hearts. You have to get all five of his events. House Visit Lunch Date Request Event House Visit Again Confession Toby will request you bring him a Rock Lobster. You can catch it fishing off Gull Island during Spring or Winter.
If your asking about Rock Lobster you can get them on Gull Island. (Then you give the rock lobster to Toby so you can marry him)
When you complete all his heart events Hamilton will apear, talk to you about the blue bird and feather, and after a few weeks you will get a cutscene.
Gill will only marry the female main character. He will never marry anyone else. Julius, Chase, Jin, Toby, and Calvin can marry a different girl but Owen, Luke, and Gill do not have anyone else that they will marry.
If you're playing as a girl: When you're up to 2 hearts with Anissa, Jin and Anissa's first heart event will trigger when you enter Souffle Farm. At three hearts, the two will get married. It's the same if you're playing as a boy, but befriend Jin instead. And be careful not to befriend your rival! Chase will marry Maya, Julius will marry Candace, Renee will marry Toby, and Calvin will marry Phoebe . Hope I helped!
Any type of fish what i do is i buy a fresh water pawn from his dad and than give it to Toby. I'm at the last bell so if you are you can buy 3 fresh water pawns and give them to ozzie Toby and poalo for gives i pay $150 and get easy hearts
You must first complete his five heart events. And then propose with the Blue Feather after you earn enough hearts with him. -Home Visit: 2 hearts -Lunch Date: 4 hearts. -Request: 5 hearts. This is different for each person. Toby will ask for a Rock Lobster -Home Visit Again: 5 hearts -Confession: 6 hearts. The person will tell you to meet him/her under Alan's tree, near Brownie Ranch. Try to get there before 10:00am. To get the Rock Lobster you must fish off of Gull Island. But you can only catch one during Winter and Spring. To raise Toby's heart levels give him a gift he likes once per day. He likes Broiled Fish.
You can't. Bo is not a marriage candidate. When playing as the female character you can choose from: Luke Gill Chase Julius Toby Jin Calvin Owen The Wizard The Harvest King But no one else.