answersLogoWhite
US Civil War
History of the United States
Confederate States of America

What are arguments for and against the South having the right to secede from the Union?


Top Answer
User Avatar
Wiki User
Answered 2011-09-13 18:01:18

Breaking any union intended to be a permanent commitment would not be something to be taken lightly, or something to be done because of only a few issues where all parties don't see eye to eye. Or because one party may get benefits for now, as things have a tenedency to balance over time. If by secedeing one means becoming independent, that would entail a number of things that probably can't be achieved under any cirumstances. And, if it were to be done fairly, wouldn't it need to consider compensating the States remaining in the union for any benefits the others had received or took with them? Certainly, the seceders must take on lots of obligations that were entered into on their behalf when they were a part of the union. All things probably financially, socially and logistically virtually impossible. Also, I'm not sure that the right to secede doesn't exist. But, that doesn't mean others would have to accept it. That is key, because while seceding or declaring independence is one thing, being considered so by others is really what establishes it. In fact, for about as long as there have been rules governing inter-governmental relations, being acknowledged as the government of a country is what actually establishes one as such. For example: the seceding Confederate states of the US were never acknowleged by any government anywhere else. An important reason for their failure. France, Spain and even England (which the US had recent wars with and by no means was particuarly supportive), the real players if you will, refused to acknolwge the Confederacy, (meaning things like they wouldn't accept their crrancy, etc.). That was true even though the confederacy did many things, especially concerning trade of cotton which these countries desperately needed, to encourage them to do so. On the other hand, Isreal was recognized by several countries, the US very importantly, within hours of declaring it's independence. That is really what established its government as an entity.

001
๐Ÿ™
0
๐Ÿคจ
0
๐Ÿ˜ฎ
0
๐Ÿ˜‚
0
User Avatar

Your Answer

Still Have Questions?

Related Questions

What caused the upper south to secede?

Slavery caused the upper south to secede.


How were north and south different?

north was against slavery while south supported it, also South wanted to secede from the union and become there own country.


What are some arguments against the use of tariffs?

The south was against the tariffs because they didn't have any industry to protect.


What issue almost cause South Carolina to secede from the union?

Tariffs on imports, which the South needed, having so little industry. Later, South Carolina became the first state to secede, following Lincoln's election on a ticket of no new slave-states.


How did South Carolina deal with the North's moral arguments against slavery?

Sucks to be you NERDS


What are helper's arguments against slavery in the south?

Go on fantage.com make an account then you will find out.


What was Lincoln's initial stance when the south began to secede?

Lincoln's initial stance when the South began to secede was to not fire on Fort Sumter. He was trying to stay out of it and allow the upper south to convince the lower south to not secede.


What did the choice between leaving the union or fighting against their fellow countrymen cause?

states in the Upper South to secede


What caused the choice between the union or fighting against their own fellow countrymen?

states in the Upper South to secede.


What state was the first to secede from the union and when did it secede?

South Carolina and in 1862


Why did the South secede when President Lincoln became President?

Because he was against slavery and most of the south states were slave states and the north was against slavery. So the south thought that Lincoln would take the births side.


Why did the north want to secede from the union?

Not the NorthThe North wanted to preserve the Union, not secede from it. The South wanted to secede.


Why did the north want to secede from the south?

The north never wanted to secede from the south. The south seceded from the north in 1860 to preserve the institution of slavery.


When and why did the south secede?

South Carolina was the first state to secede in October of 1860. The South seceded because of slavery issues & constitutional issues.


What was The South Carolina Exposition?

The South Carolina Exposition was a protest by the state of South Carolina against the Tariff of 1828. The document stated that without repealing the tariff South Carolina would secede.


Did South Carolina secede?

yes in fact they were the first states to secede from the union


Who were the first confederate states to secede from the union?

South Carolina was the first to secede.


Who is the 1st state to secede?

South Carolina was the first state to secede from the Union.


What war included slavery arguments?

The American Civil War..The South against the North..the south wanted slavery..the north didn't...


Why did South Carolina secede from the Union in 1820?

South Carolina did not secede from the Union in 1820. South Carolina announced its secession on December 20, 1860.


Which Southern state was the first to secede in 1860?

South Carolina was the first to secede in 1860


Which state was the first of eleven states to secede from the union?

South Carolina was the first to secede.


What did the south do when Lincoln won?

secede


Who wanted south to secede?

Secessionist


What was the state of secede?

South Carolina


Still have questions?