1.pig
2.water bucket
3.flag
24 Carrot Island was the 4th island on Poptropica, and officially opened after the first three islands (Early Poptropica, Shark Tooth, and Time Tangled) in late 2007.
give them to who needs them
You can finish all the islands, but you can not beat poptropica because they add a new island every two or three months.OF COURSE
the pig bucket and flag
When you have returned all three missing items to the villagers of Early Poptropica, a ship will dock at the pier. The captain will give you the Island Medallion.
When you have completed returning the three missing items, a boat will dock at the pier in Early Poptropica village. The captain will give you the Island Medallion.
shark tooth reality TV spy and early poptropica island
When you have returned all three items on Early Poptropica, a sailing ship will dock at the pier. Go aboard and receive your Island Medallion.
When you have returned all three missing items to Early Poptropica village, a ship will dock at the pier on the right. The captain will give you the Island Medallion.
The Island Medallion is awarded by the ship's captain when you have restored all three items including the Signal Flag. (The Island Medallion for an island is awarded concurrently with your 100 credit bonus for completing it.)
The first island (one of the first three) is Early Poptropica from 2007. (see the related question below)
Once you return the three items, the island is complete. The signal flag will be raised, and a ship will dock at the Early Poptropica harbor. The captain will give you the Island Medallion.