Yes, "The Reckoning" could make a good horror story title. It carries a sense of final judgment or punishment, which can create an air of suspense and mystery around the story.
You're going about it backwards, I'm afraid -- the title comes from what you've written, not first! Finish your story and then decide if that's a good title.
The Mystery of Marie Roget
mystery
A good mystery should draw the reader in and make them curious about what's going to happen, and it should give a satisfying ending for the mystery in the story.
The title comes from the story -- finish the story first and you will find a good title from what you've written. Click the related link to learn how to tell if your writing is any good or not!
You think of a mystery that has never been solved -- you can make one up if you want! -- and write what happened.
The title must come from your story! Write the story first, then your title will have come to you from what you wrote.
surfing
Carolyn Keene enjoyed writing mystery stories.
The title comes from the story, not the other way around! Finish your story and you'll find the title from what you've written.
The title must come from your story, not the other way around! Write the story first, and then you can find the title yourself!