Best Answer

There have been tremendous interpretations and mis-interpretations over these two words , Jaati, and Varna by lots of scholars of Indian society on this matter.

A branch of people believes that Jaati is a profession-based categorization of Hindu masses whereas a Varna is a color based categorization of Hindu masses.! People , the scholars, have even cited refernces from many Vedic documents to make their assertion and to prove them. But what sounds surprising to me is point that none of the scholars, particularly the English scholars, have attempted to understand the contextual sense of what the authors of those vedic documents have attempted to mean when they speak something about these two systems. For example, one cited Vedic document speaks that the four Varna/Jaati, whatever one may treat that for the time being, were created from the limbs of Manu-- the Brahmins being those from his head and mouth, the Kashtriya being his Arms and hand, the Vaishya being his torso and Sudra being his Legs...and for normal functioning of the society all have to do their duty, like for the case of human body.

Is it not surprising that scholar fail to mention the metaphor involved in the description above?? Does it anywhere mention that Brahmins were created from the head of Manu, to be taken as a serious note answer for "what is the origin of Brahmins ?" , or for that matter , " what is the origin of Kashtirya ?".

Similarly the word varna which duly has one of its meaning as Color, as in "woh shaym varna ke the " (he was of dark complexion). From this, a derivative comes that Varna was about color discrimination, and this further supported by another Vedic Document which mentions that Brahmins were fair complexioned, the Kastriya were Red, Vaishya were yellow , and Sudra weer black !

Being a Hindu, I have hardly felt the existence of color discrimination in our people, although a preference for a "gori bahu" (a fair complexioned bride) is seen. But even then, the above remains only a simili/metaphor in my opinion, while the vedic author of the above might have been attempting to theorise how the Varna difference might be showing up, (as in, a V-shape underwear may mean that the wearer is likely to be a sporty chap, or 'Lord Lochinvar' means he was a noble person, although he was a 'the highway man'), which the English Scholars of Indians Sociology have almost successfully managed to thrust in the minds of our, Hindu youngsters, to the extent that color discrimination might begin now, even when nobody is red or yellow. While a 'dark Brahmin' may be actually falling out with his distractors about his Brahmin status, or otherway, the standards of 'Fair complexion' as assigned to the Brahmin club.!!

That will be the tragic irony of myths created by English Scholars while studying Indian System, which is prone to accepting the outside observer as a Judge impartial !!

The word Jaati I think remains that of the Vedic origion, but has to treated as something connoting a tribe. There are other usages, such as Jan-jaati, janya, to mean the 'club of people' but , as i see them, referentially to mean the Tribe of people who share a common descent. It is in this regard that there are Vedic mentions of 'Panchjanya' to mean the five tribes of early vedic people. A janjaati is impling- 'those people who are commonly found in a given territorial area', a small town, of a forest region, etc. Thus a Jaati, spoken of as Caste in English ('casto' a Portuguese origin for the word caste), is suppose to mean a birth/hereditrical/genetic categorisation of people.

A Varna on the other hand is likely to mean a work/profession based categorisation. The word, Varna, has an alternate meaning as "categorisation/ distinction/ or description' (a close derivative of Varga; Varnamalameant the alphabets in Sanskrit; the word "Varanan' means the act of describing something. ), itself, apart from the previous meaning 'Color'.

Thus a person from any Jaati was accepted to come to any Varna depending upon how he fared-- behaved/conducted/practised his vocation.

The examples of Jaati would be-- Saini, Kurmi, yadav, raghuvansh, jaat, Puru, khatri, etc.

But for the Varna-- there are only four of them-- Brahmin, Kshtriya, Vaishya, Shudra.

It is here that one can note there is no Jaati as Brahmin. In fact, all the four Varna are Status only, which people from any of the several Jaati attain by virtue of their accomplishment. But the modern Indian scholars, and also the common people, interpret it as one and same, which for some natural psychological causes is not too far from reality for the reason that Children do acquire the traits if the parents better than anyone else, and hence become almost one and the same. The further affirming of uch mistaken belief of seeing them as one is attibutable to the treatment and recognisation to the system in this manner by the past Invading rulers of India, the Moghuls and the British.

Another cause of confusion of Jaati and Varna to come around in Indian society was the fact that the descendants of the Varna- Brahmin, the people who attained a high state of wisdom, the Brahmmah , and thus provided discretion on Good and Evil, and also gave Prudence thoughts to the people at large from rest of the Varna, the descedants attempted to retain their high social status, by releasing it from the clutches of continuous attainment of wisdom, the Brahmmah, by putting Brahmin also as a Jaati. This was one of the first cases of moral corruption by high wisdom people. One can very plainly note that among all Jaati and Varna as known to Indian system today,only the Brahmin are both (!!) a Jaati and also a Varna. The causes of this can be plainly understood, and more when one tries to explore the origin of Brahmin as Jaati in the Vedic Literature.

User Avatar

Wiki User

12y ago
This answer is:
User Avatar
Study guides

A survey question that asks you to write a brief explanation is called

Auto correlation and cross correlation

If a married man cheats does that mean there are problems in his marriage

The nature-nurture question asks whether

See all cards
831 Reviews

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: What is the difference between class and caste?
Write your answer...
Still have questions?
magnify glass
Continue Learning about Sociology

What is the difference of caste and class?

Caste may have been derived from a community associated with a particular type of work for livelyhood in life. Where as class is associated with a status (monetary) in the society or associated with the classifications of governance.

What is the difference in the caste system of India and the class system of the US?

In India, whatever your parents are, you are. Until your next life, you will always be in the same caste. In America, if you get a higher job by being promoted, and you make more money you could go from low class to middle class or middle to high class.

How is India's caste system different from the Aryan social class system?

India's caste system is different from the Aryan social class because the Indian's marriages were only permitted only between persons of the same class. I hope I was a help!

Does gadde surname belongs to schedule caste?

GADDE surname belongs to KAMMA caste,which is one of the Forward Caste(High Class) in South India.

How do you contrast the caste system with a class system?

So..... you wanna know how the Indian caste system is different to the American class system. Here, I'll help you. The Indian caste system, or varna came about when the Aryans began speaking nomadic groups came to India about 1500 BC. The Aryan priests divided society into a caste system with four parts. The priests( Brachmins) were the highest varna, the second caste was Kshatriyas, or rulers and warriors. Third in ran was the vaisyas( farmers, craftspeople and traders.) and the lowest ranking was the sudras and they were the workers and servants. People couldn't change their caste. They had to marry and socialize with people from their own caste. In the United States class is determined by how much wealth you have, not usually by your occupation. The 3 classes are upper class, middle class, and lower class. Most Americans fall into middle class or lower class with the very wealthiest people in the upper class. In American society, you aren't forced into one class. Our system is not based on religion like the caste system is. Hope that answers your question!! And i hope somebody answer the question to this. Compare the Indian caste system to the American class system.

Related questions

What is the differene between caste system and class system?

In a class, you can depending how well you do, improve from one class to another class. In the caste system, one is born in a caste, and cannot move to another caste, except by reincarnation

Difference between caste and tribes?

Caste is a social hierarchy determined by birth in a community by tradition of work dependent in society while tribe is a smaller social class of people speaking the same language.

Difference between bc and obc castes?

bc-backword caste obc-other backward caste

What is the difference of caste and class?

Caste may have been derived from a community associated with a particular type of work for livelyhood in life. Where as class is associated with a status (monetary) in the society or associated with the classifications of governance.

What is difference between bc and bcm caste?

BC is a general Backward caste BCM is a backward caste specially for muslim community ppl....

What's the difference between the Class 365 and Class 465 466?

The difference between the Class 365 and Class 465, 466 is basically the cost.

Difference between exclusive or inclusive class intervals?

difference between inclusive and exclusive class interval

What is the fifth class of the caste system?

The Sudras is the 5th class of the Caste System.

What is difference between first class and second class on train trips?

What is the difference between buying a 1st class and a 2nd class ticket on the train in England?

Was brahmins a social class of the caste system?

Yes it was the lowest class in the caste system

What is the difference between national and public holidays?

srivastava is top caste in kasthaya

What was the caste system?

The Caste System divided people into groups....the Upper class..THe Middle Class..and The lower class.