Atreyu lives on Turtle Isle.
You start in Loyada's house.
CarpenterSan can be found in his house on Dumbbell Isle.
Should be a house or store in Treeton. =)
There is no Pawneer on HorseIsle 2 like there is on the original HorseIsle game. Instead, there is an auction house where a player can allow the "foreign bidder" bid on an unwanted horse. If this bidder wins the auction, the horse will be removed from the game.
Oddly lives on Magma Isle, west of Venus' house.
It's on Plains Isle at SirCamelHair's house.
Flipperton, behind Helga's house. ~Nobody from brown server~
Mr. Turtle is on Turtle Isle. He is in the house just above the town.
She lives on art isle. Her house is on the snowy part.
Search left of the first palm tree above the tanagrama near her house.
In the barrel next to the house :) LlamaToffee
Plains Isle, SirCamelHair's house. Plus the blue dye is there too! -AppleStarlight