0
Who did Bonnie Prince Charles ask to pick the battle field at Culloden?
Wiki User
∙ 10y ago
Charles Stuart chose to fight at Drumossie Moor - as the place was called then - himself, against the advice of his competent military commander and adviser Lord George Murray. The terrain favoured Cumberland's trained and disciplined troops, and Murray counselled him to move to a more defensible position, or disband his force and allow the men to return to their homes. The two men had little respect for each other, this had grown into active dislike during the campaign, and Stuart ignored him. The reasons for this decision? It's still debated, but many historians agree that their personal animosity played a major role in it. The Jacobites had won at Preston Pans and Falkirk, but they had the advantage of surprise, the government forces were poorly commanded, and he may have overestimated his Highlanders' ability to fight a pitched battle. Some have also suggested that he was driven by a vainglorious ego and do or die romanticism.
Wiki User
∙ 10y ago
Add your answer:
Earn +20 pts
What battles did bonnie prince charlie fight in?
Well in my class i learned bonnie prince charlie fought for the Jacobites and their enemys were the hanovarians people call them the red coats.The jacobites and the red coats had a war and they fought a culloden battlefield. (the leader of the red coats was William of orange.)
What would happen if bonnie prince charlie picked another battlefield instead of culloden?
If he had listened to his Generals and chose another site for the battle as well as another time. He may well have won. According the learning officer from Culloden battlefield, Duncan Cook, the prince could not have lasted much longer as supplies were dwindling and men were leaving. Maybe one more battle, maybe not, but he could not have won,
Was Bonnie Prince Charles a good or bad leader?
No, he led his army into battle not thinking of the bad cause it would make.
Why did the government army win the battle of culloden?
why the jacobites lostThey didn't have enough menthey picked boggy grounds to fightthey were tired hungry and hadn't slept for two daysbadly lead
What battle in 1746 ultimately led to the defeat of the Jacobites?
The Battle of Culloden.
What battles did bonnie prince charlie fight in?
Well in my class i learned bonnie prince charlie fought for the Jacobites and their enemys were the hanovarians people call them the red coats.The jacobites and the red coats had a war and they fought a culloden battlefield. (the leader of the red coats was William of orange.)
What did bonnie prince charlie have to do with the united kingdom?
Prince Charles Edward Louis John Casimir Sylvester Severino Maria Stuart was the son of James Francis Edward Stuart. This made him the grandson of James I of England(and VI of Scotland simultaneously). As a result of this, Prince Charles saw himself as a rightful heir to the throne of the United Kingdom. He staged the Jacobite Rising of 1745 and was defeated at the battle of at the Battle of Culloden. So, in answer to this question, "Bonnie Prince Charlie's" association with the United Kingdom is that of a rebellious Scot with royal descent.
Why is the battle between France and Great Britain called Culloden?
There is a misunderstanding from the questioner. The battle of Culloden was fought between the British government and Jacobites. The Jacobites wanted to place Prince Charles Edward Stuart on the throne of Great Britain.
What would happen if bonnie prince charlie picked another battlefield instead of culloden?
If he had listened to his Generals and chose another site for the battle as well as another time. He may well have won. According the learning officer from Culloden battlefield, Duncan Cook, the prince could not have lasted much longer as supplies were dwindling and men were leaving. Maybe one more battle, maybe not, but he could not have won,
Was Bonnie Prince Charles a good or bad leader?
No, he led his army into battle not thinking of the bad cause it would make.
Why did the battle of culloden happen?
because Prince Charles edward Stuart thought that the throne rightfully belonged to the Stuart family, because James II had been kicked off the throne in 1688 so Prince Charles edward Stuart tried to fight it back.
Who is the skye boat song written aboat?
The Skye Boat Song is a Scottish folk song that tells the story of Bonnie Prince Charlie's escape from the Isle of Skye after his defeat at the Battle of Culloden in 1746. The lyrics are written from the perspective of a supporter of the prince who helps him escape to safety.
Who were the leaders at the battle of Culloden?
Bonnie Prince Charlie (or Charles Edward Stuart known as the Young pretender) led the Jacobites, his senior commander was Lord George Murray (the Duke of Atholl's son). The Duke of Cumberland (William Augustus - Younger son of George II) led the Government forces. The two were in fact cousins.
Why is a sweet William called stinking billy in Scotland?
Highlanders named common ragwort Stinking Billy after William Duke of Cumberland put down Bonnie Prince Charlies rebellion at the battle of Culloden 1746. The English named the garden flower Sweet William in his honor.
9 In which famous battle was the army of Bonnie Prince Charlie defeated?
BLOB
Was the Battle of Stirling Bridge agenst William Wallace and Edward 1st?
it was culloden Yes, is the correct answer, NOT Culloden.
Why did the government army win the battle of culloden?
why the jacobites lostThey didn't have enough menthey picked boggy grounds to fightthey were tired hungry and hadn't slept for two daysbadly lead
