Kat Edorsson was blindsided and eliminated from the game on May 2nd, 2012.
RC was voted off the island on October 31st, 2012.
If you are referring to who got voted off second on the first season of Survivor, Survivor: Borneo, it was B.B. Andersen.
Michael Jefferson was eliminated during this episode.
Debra Beebe was eliminated from Survivor on May 7th, 2009.
Jonathan Penner was voted off the island and saw his torch snuffed on November 28th, 2012.
Colleen
If you are talking about Survivor for May 11, 2011, then no. Grant got voted off. And Sunday May 15, 2011 is the season 2-hour finale.
Amanda Kimmel was voted off of Survivor Heroes vs. Villains on that particular airdate.
Randy
No Survivor contestant was voted off on April 9th. However, Joe Dowdle was removed due to injury on this episode.
Randy
Rob Mariano was eliminated from Survivor Heroes vs. Villains on the April 1st, 2010 episode of Survivor.