No pope ever authorized the sale of indulgences, that would be simony, and a very serious sin. Indulgences were always issued for good works, accompanied by prayer for the Pope, Sacramental confession, and Sacramental Communion. Up until the protestant revolt, one of those good works used to include almsgiving, but due to issues back then, that has been discontinued.
Nobody ever ordered the Church to sell indulgences, that would be a very serious sin known as simony. Although there were some abuses of indulgences during the sixteenth century, the vast majority of "facts that everyone knows" about indulgences were made up out of thin air by people revolting against the Church. The fact that these lies are still believed hundreds of years later is very disturbing.
* *
The ninety five thesis
The selling of Indulgences was stopped after the Reformation, was practiced only by certain unscrupulous individuals .
No pope ever urged anyone to sell indulgences. Selling indulgences is a grievous sin and always has been.
The Catholic Church, through its agents, the popes, cardinals and bishops, would sell indulgences. This practice has ceased.
Roman Catholic AnswerThe Church never sold anything to replace penance. There were some abuses connected with indulgences issued for donations to help repair St. Peter's in Rome, in the sixteenth century, and the indulgences replaced penance, but the Church has never offered them for sale, and due to the abuses, indulgences are now never offered for alms.
indulgences
Martin Luther was the reformer who challenged the Catholic Church over Indulgences.
the indulgences that the church sold.
PARDONER
Indulgences
Both men believed that the Catholic Church should end the sale of indulgences.