Jacob wins the fight.
edward wins Bella for ever....but Jacob imprints on there daughter! :0 omg!!! lol
They didn't fight. Bella stepped dramatically between them and said "you can't hurt each other without hurting me".
Edward gets Bella and Jacob falls in love with Renesmee
Edward doesn't fight anyone physically. Jane uses her powers on him. Aro reads his mind. Felix and Demetri bring him to Aro and his brothers.
It is Edward who wins out at the end of Breaking Dawn.
in my opinion edward does. he has Bella in the beginning. then when he leaves her she doesnt stop thinking about him and would take him back in a heart beat. Jacob helps Bella in the middle and wants a relationship with her but she wont give it to him. then when edward does comes back in the end Bella goes to him in a heartbeat and tells Jacob he should leave at the very end. so in my opinion edward wins the whole entire movie of New Moon.
edward wins
Edward. Edward wins her heart. Jacob has it too for a bit, but she loves Edward and that's that. Jacob tries to make himself imprinted to her, like Sam and Emily, but it doesn't work because it only comes naturally.
edward, jacob,and bella
In the end of the third book, "Eclipse," the Cullens and the werewolves join forces to fight against a group of rogue vampires led by Victoria. During the battle, Victoria is defeated and killed, ensuring the safety of Bella. The Cullens and the werewolves emerge victorious.
Spike would win all the way Edward is like Gay at fighting I mean like he can fight but not as good as Spike . If Spike gets a good punch the fight is over. Spike Wins
In New Moon no one wins, Edward leaves because he feels that his presence in Bella's life is a bad thing and leaves her. Bella becomes depressed and seeks a friendship with Jacob Black. They become best friends and Bella begins considering becoming his girlfriend even though she knows it will be nothing like when she was with Edward. Then after thinking Bella had died jumping off a cliff he wanted to kill himself by provoking the Volturi. Bella and Alice go to rescue him and after it is sorted Bella goes back with Edward. There is no winning between Jacob and Edward although once you read/see Eclipse it becomes quite the opposite. If you want to fully understand I suggest reading the series as they are much more detailed than the movies. New Moon is a very internal struggle for Bella and is best experienced through the book. Hope this helps. God Bless.