answersLogoWhite

0


Best Answer

because the notion of the perfect island of Gaunilon does not necessarily includes exisrente. it does only exist in the mind because the notion of the perfect island of Gaunilon does not necessarily includes exisrente. it does only exist in the mind

User Avatar

Wiki User

βˆ™ 15y ago
This answer is:
User Avatar
More answers
User Avatar

AnswerBot

βˆ™ 5d ago

Gaunilon objected to Anselm's proof because he believed that using the concept of the greatest conceivable being to prove God's existence was flawed. He argued that just because something could be conceived as the greatest does not mean it necessarily exists in reality. Therefore, he questioned the validity of Anselm's ontological argument.

This answer is:
User Avatar

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: Why did Gaunilon object to St Anselms proof of Gods existence?
Write your answer...
Submit
Still have questions?
magnify glass
imp
Continue Learning about Philosophy

Why is that proof for God's existence is something that people continue to attempt regardless of it being impossible and why is it impossible?

People continue to attempt to prove God's existence because it is a deeply personal and philosophical question that has puzzled humanity for centuries. It is considered impossible to provide irrefutable proof due to the nature of faith and the lack of empirical evidence that can definitively prove the existence of a higher power. Belief in God is subjective and rooted in individual beliefs and experiences, making it a matter of faith rather than scientific proof.


WHAt does I think therefore I am mean?

"I think, therefore I am" is a famous quote by philosopher RenΓ© Descartes, which highlights the importance of self-awareness and consciousness. It suggests that thinking is proof of one's existence, as the act of doubting or thinking about one's own existence confirms the fact that one exists as a thinking being.


How does descartes prove that he exists?

Descartes famously said "Cogito, ergo sum" or "I think, therefore I am." He argued that even if he was being deceived by an evil demon, the act of doubting his existence still indicated his own existence as a thinking thing. Therefore, the very act of thinking proved his existence.


What is Rene Descartes's famous philosophical dictum?

Rene Descartes's famous philosophical dictum is "I think, therefore I am" (in Latin: "Cogito, ergo sum"). This statement emphasizes the idea that the act of thinking itself is proof of one's own existence.


Which kind of proof combines statements and reasons into sentences?

A paragraph proof combines statements and reasons into sentences to prove a mathematical statement or theorem. Each statement is followed by a reason or justification, typically in a linear format to demonstrate the logical progression of the proof.

Related questions

Do you have proof of mermaids existence?

No. There is no proof of the existence of mermaids because they do not exist.


Is there any proof that Buddha existence?

The teachings of the Buddha are the most evident proof for his existence.


Where to get proof of existence?

There is none!


How do you prove the existence of back EMF?

How do you proof of the existence of back emf ?


How many yetis are left in the world?

there is no actual proof that there are any yetis in existence.


Where can you find the video of the proof of God's existence?

There is no proof of God existing, though there is also no proof that he doesn't. It's all a matter of belief, until we can prove or disprove God's existence.


Who made the 5 poofs for the existence of god?

a proof of something is a undisputable fact therefore "God" has no proof on existence because no man knows 100% he's there


Who is the man who discovered the proof of God's existence?

Adam.


Is there any hard proof of the existence of Die Glocke?

No


Is there solid proof of a cryptid?

The definition of a cryptid is that there is not absolute proof of its existence, such as a live specimen or carcass. However, animals which used to be cryptids have been proven, such as the coelacanth, the okapi, and the platypus, now have solid proof of their existence. Animals which are currently regarded as cryptids may have a large volume of evidence for their existence, but it is not considered solid proof of the animal by the scientific community.


Is there any scientific proof to the existence of Faeries?

winx club


Is there objective existence in the world?

It absolutely does. Your precious self is the proof.