0
Why did members of the third estate think the estates- general was unfair?
Wiki User
∙ 7y ago
They thought the general estate was unfair because they had much more privileges than they did. Because of the Enlightment, the Third Estate wanted equality and liberty. They were also inspired by the American Revolution and began questioning the structure of their society.
Halie Lockman
Wiki User
∙ 9y agoThe members of the Third Estate felt under-represented because they did not hold the political or social sway that the other two states had. The First Estate was the clergy and the Second Estate was the nobility, this meant that they had a great deal of political, social and monetary sway which would have given them more power than the Third Estate.
Wiki User
∙ 13y agowhy might members of the third estate have felt under-represented at the meeting of the estates general in may 1789?
1 / A succession of poor grain harvests in previous years (1777/1778) from which the mass confusion of French peasant and recurrent famines. 2 / As in previous centuries and decades under the Ancien Regime, the people were ruthlessly crushed under taxes and various gabelles. 3 / A animosity (tinged with xenophobia) cons considered haughty Marie Antoinette (apparently it wrongly!) by the French people from Louis XVI a lack of political vision and vision for the future, he was also often judged by his contemporaries rather limited and intellectually unfit to lead France (in a notebook he kept daily on 14 July 1789, he wrote "nothing to report ") 4 / A desire to overthrow the monarchy and create a sharp break with the ancien regime (especially the important character-leaders like Robespierre, Danton, Saint-Just ... etc.) 5 / The flight of Varennes contributed to rebel even more people outraged by the attempt of the royal couple to evade justice. 6 / In my view, the movement reached a high point of January 21, 1793 during the execution of the royal couple, at this point, we have thought that the monarchy had been in France his term.
Add your answer:
Earn +20 pts
Why did members of the third estate think the estate's general was unfair?
They thought the general estate was unfair because they had much more privileges than they did. Because of the Enlightment, the Third Estate wanted equality and liberty. They were also inspired by the American Revolution and began questioning the structure of their society.
Why did the Third Estate object to each estate having one vote in the Estates-General?
It was unfair for each estate to have one vote because the first and second estate would always out-vote the third estate, seeing they have more common interests. Moreover, the third estate encompassed 97% of the French population yet they only receive one vote in the Estate's General.
Why did the third estate refuse to follow the tradition of each estate having one vote?
It was unfair for each estate to have one vote because the first and second estate would always out-vote the third estate, seeing they have more common interests. Moreover, the third estate encompassed 97% of the French population yet they only receive one vote in the Estate's General.
Why were the three estates fighting?
The nature of the Estates themselves were not a problem. The relative power in comparison to their numbers was seen as a problem by the Third Estate which made up between 95 and 97% of the population of France. To continue to give the Catholic Church and the Nobility an equal vote and voice was deemed as unfair in the Age of Enlightenment. It was time to change the rules of the Ancient Regieme.
What were the complaints of the Third Estate during the French Revolution?
An unfair tax code.
Why did the third estate object to each estates having one vote in the estates general?
It was unfair for each estate to have one vote because the first and second estate would always out-vote the third estate, seeing they have more common interests. Moreover, the third estate encompassed 97% of the French population yet they only receive one vote in the Estate's General.
Why did members of the third estate think the estate's general was unfair?
They thought the general estate was unfair because they had much more privileges than they did. Because of the Enlightment, the Third Estate wanted equality and liberty. They were also inspired by the American Revolution and began questioning the structure of their society.
Why did the third third estate object to each estate's having one vote in the estates-general?
It was unfair for each estate to have one vote because the first and second estate would always out-vote the third estate, seeing they have more common interests. Moreover, the third estate encompassed 97% of the French population yet they only receive one vote in the Estate's General.
Why did the Third Estate object to each estate having one vote in the Estates-General?
It was unfair for each estate to have one vote because the first and second estate would always out-vote the third estate, seeing they have more common interests. Moreover, the third estate encompassed 97% of the French population yet they only receive one vote in the Estate's General.
What was the events that influenced the French Revolution in 1800?
The large public debt and the unfair tax code which gave the nobles and the Catholic Church tax free status coupled with a government that was not representative or responsive to the majority of the population.
What where the three estates during the french revolution?
the 3 estates during the French Revolution were; members of the clergy made up the 1st estate, nobles the 2nd estate, and the rest of the people the 3rd estate. the 3rd estate included the working people of the cities and a large and prosperous middle class made up chiefly of merchants, lawyers, and government officials.
What unfair conditions existed in pre- revolutionary France?
1. The first and second estates were exempt from most taxes (taille, or land tax), while the third estate was not 2. The third estate was forced to pay feudal dues to the nobles and the king 3. There was no redress for the land damage of the third estate homes 4. The higher estates banned hunting that was necessary for survival among the people of the third estate
Why did the third estate refuse to follow the tradition of each estate having one vote?
It was unfair for each estate to have one vote because the first and second estate would always out-vote the third estate, seeing they have more common interests. Moreover, the third estate encompassed 97% of the French population yet they only receive one vote in the Estate's General.
How was the third estate treated unfairly?
The three estates had an equal vote in the Estates General, which gave the first estate (clergy) and the second estate (nobility) both equal presence with the third estate. This was problematic for two reasons. The first issue was that these votes were vastly out of proportion with the amount of people that they represented. The third estate was 97-98% of the French population, but had only 33% of the vote. The second issue was that the equal votes of the first and second estate served as an effective veto to oppose any changes or improvements which the third estate would request, effectively making the third estate unable to use the Estates General as a vehicle to benefit them in any way.
What was the estate system unfair in France?
One Estate paid all the taxes.
What event was considered to be the spark of the french revolution?
There were several events that led to the French Revolution. The biggest cause was the poor and horrible living conditions of the people of France while the King and his wife lived a very lavish lifestyle.
Why was the tax system unfair towards the third estate?
It took everything from them
