0
Why do Sahih al-Bukhari and Sahih al-Muslim have different hadiths?
Wiki User
∙ 9y ago
The names of the collections come from the fact that the collections were seen to refer to the roughly 10% of Hadiths that were accurate or sahih (صØÙŠØ) in Arabic. The second name refers to the scholar who compiled the list, al-Bukhari (البخاري) or al-Muslim (المسلم). The two scholars, even though they used the same method to determine which hadiths were sahih and which were not, came up with distinct lists of what hadiths they believed were sahih. While they agreed on a large number of hadiths, the disagreements are noticeable and this is why there are different hadiths in the different collection. Other hadith collectors, like Abu Darda have still other hadiths that they consider sahih, but are rejected by both al-Bukhari and al-Muslim.
Wiki User
∙ 9y ago
Wiki User
∙ 9y agoThere have been a large collection of Hadith. Both the Imams selected out of the waste number of Hadith. Many of the Hadiths are same in the two books.
Add your answer:
Earn +20 pts
What is Islam's book of sayings?
The Hadiths. (These have been collected in several collections of which Sahih Al-Bukhari and Sahih Al-Muslim are the most respected.)
How many hadiths is it?
How many?If you mean how many hadith narrations there are, the answer is "lots", but sunni Muslims regard 5 hadith collections as Authentic narrations these include Sahih Bukhari, Sahih Muslim, Imam Malik's Muwatta, Sunan Al-Tirmidhi, Sunan An-Nasai and Sunan Abu Daud. Collectively they have around thousands of hadiths.
What are the three classifications of Hadiths and what do they mean?
The Hadith literature was aggregated 150 years after the death of Muhammad and the major Islamic scholars or 3ulemaa (علماء) noted that numerous things crept into the Hadith literature that were clearly not from Muhammad's life or his views including: Zoroastrian Proverbs, Jewish Psalms, provisions for increasing the flour content of cookies (you cannot make this stuff up), etc. Recognizing the prevalence of these forgeries, there are three classifications of Hadith literature in Traditional Islam developed: da'if (ضائف) - weak, hassan (حسن) - good, and sahih (صحيح) - pure/healthy. They classified the Hadiths by their chains to transmission, the amount of different transmission methods that they went through, and how likely they would have been to have occurred. For example, the Hadiths listed above (Zoroastrian Proverbs et al.) were seen to be da'if - weak. The Hadith collectors worked with 300,000 Hadiths and saw less than 10% of them to be sahih - pure and therefore worth following. Those collections became named "Sahih" followed by the collector's name, i.e. Sahih al-Bukhari or Sahih al-Muslim, etc.
What are the problems with the hadith?
Unfortunately, many of the Hadiths have not been correctly described. Anyhow, the Six authentic collections of Hadith, especially Sahih Bokhari and Sahih Muslim are the most authentic collections of Hadith.
What is it about the Hadith that modernist Muslims find both disturbing and embarrassing?
It is not the concept of the Hadith themselves that Modernist Muslims find disturbing or embarrassing, but the several of the Hadiths which advocate for:Anti-Semitism (Claims that Jews must be killed for there to be peace in the World: Sahih Bukhari 4:56:791)Violence against women (Discussions on Wife-Beating: Sahih Muslim 4:2127)Execution of apostates (Man converts to Judaism from Islam and Executed for this: Sahih Bukhari 9:89:271)The difference in value of a human life depending on a person's religion (No Muslim should be executed for the murder of a Non-Muslim because they are not equal: Sahih Bukhari 1:3:111)Mass killings ordered by Mohammed (The Massacre at Khaybar:Sahih Bukhari 5:59:512)Numerous other unacceptable issues in modern-society.The sad thing is that too few Muslims are disturbed or embarrassed by these Hadiths.
Give a proof where the Prophet Muhammad advises good behavior towards his companions?
First of all you search Sahih Hadiths He rejected gambling which is very bad He rejected drinking as we know by alcoholic habits there are somany problems in the world See Quran 22:40,6:108,3:110,5:90
What is an object depicting the teachings of the prophet Muhammad?
The question hinges on the words "teachings of the Prophet Muhammad". You are likely looking for the QUR'AN, which is the Islamic Holy Book, but Muslims will argue that these teachings are God's teachings with Muhammad serving only as a communication-device. In this view, the Qur'an cannot be Muhammad's teachings as they have nothing to do with his thoughts on any matter.If you are specifically interested in books containing Muhammad's personal teachings, I would recommend the HADITH COLLECTIONS, which are books assembled by Islamic Scholars of sayings and doings (Hadiths) attributed to Muhammad. Probably the most respected Hadith Collection in Sunni Islam is Sahih Bukhari followed closely by Sahih Muslim. (Sahih, means healthy, e.g. the recollection is bona fide.)
Is eve mentioned by name in sahih bukhari?
yes
What is the importance of hazrat ayesha in Islam?
Ayesha Bent Abu Bakr Al-Seddeeq, May Allah pleased with the two( her & her father) is a very important Muslim character. Actually,talking about her needs alot .But I'll tell you few points about her :1. She is one of the wives of the prophet Muhammad PBUH (the third wife),she is thus called "Mother of the Believers" as all the wives of the prophet PBUH.2. She is quoted as source for many hadith, sacred traditions about Muhammad's life, with Muhammad's personal life being the topic of most narrations. She narrated a huge number of hadiths out of which are mentioned in both Sahih al-Bukhari and Sahih Muslim "the most trustful books of hadiths of the prophet Muhammad PBUH ".3.Historians see Aisha as the learned clever woman, who tirelessly recounted stories from the life of Muhammad and explained Muslim history and traditions. She is considered to be one of the foremost scholars of Islam's early age with some historians accrediting up to one-quarter of the Islamic Sharia (Islamic religious law), based on the collection of hadiths, to have stemmed from her narrations.4. She was famous for her great morals & her charity works.
What book contains the collected teachings of the prophet Muhammad?
The folowing books are the most famous collectings of the sayings of Hazrat Muhammad SAW.: 1. Al-Sahih Al-Bokhari 2. Al Sahih Al-Muslim, 3. Mota Imam Malik, 4. Tirmazi Sharif, 5. Ibn-i-Maja
What are the three books where Islamic teachings can be found?
The qur'an is the basic source of Islam. Other books are the collections of the sayings of holy Prophet (SAW) like Sahih Bokhari, Sahih Muslim and Mota Imam Malik.
What did the text use to study the teachings of Islam?
The Holy Quran and Sahih Hadith
