answersLogoWhite

0


Best Answer

The Supreme Court heard the case under original jurisdiction because the Judiciary Act of 1789 assigned to the Court the responsibility for all writs of mandamus. However, John Marshall determined the Constitution hadn't granted the Supreme Court subject matter jurisdiction over Marbury's case, and that the proper initial venue would be federal District Court.

Therefore, while the Court determined Marbury was entitled to his commission, they couldn't compel Secretary of State Madison to deliver it. Had Marbury wanted to pursue the matter further, he would have to refile in District Court. If he wasn't granted satisfaction in the lower courts, then the Supreme Court could properly hear his petition under its appellate jurisdiction.

Marbury never refiled the case, and never became justice of the peace.

Case Citation:

Marbury v. Madison, 5 US 137 (1803)

User Avatar

Wiki User

13y ago
This answer is:
User Avatar

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: When the US Supreme Court heard Marbury vs Madison was it under original jurisdiction or appellate jurisdiction?
Write your answer...
Submit
Still have questions?
magnify glass
imp
Continue Learning about American Government

Did William Marbury ever get the commission that Marbury v Madison said he had a right to?

No. In the opinion of the Court, Marshall declared Marbury was entitled to his commission, but that the Supreme Court didn't have original jurisdiction to issue the writ of mandamus Marbury requested. Marshall explicitly stated Marbury would have to refile his case in a lower court first, then appeal to the Supreme Court if he failed to get relief at that level. Marbury never refiled his case.Case Citation:Marbury v. Madison, 5 US 137 (1803)For more information, see Related Questions, below.


What was the name of the supreme court case of marbury vs Madison?

marbury vs. Madison


In Marbury v. Madison did Marbury have a right to the office of Justice of the Peace?

According to Chief Justice John Marshall, yes. All the proper steps had been taken to secure Marbury's commission under former President John Adams. The only step that had not been completed before the administration changed was delivery of the documents, which then-Secretary of State John Marshall assumed incoming Secretary of State James Madison would take care of as a matter of course.Marshall didn't foresee Madison's delay in reaching Washington, nor Jefferson's intervention in the commissions' distribution. Nevertheless, all the legal steps had been completed correctly, and the commissions completed during Adams' administration.Marshall ruled that, while Marbury and the other plaintiffs were legally entitled to their positions as justices of the peace, the Supreme Court lacked authority to grant the writ of mandamus (court order compelling Madison complete delivery) under their original (trial) jurisdiction. Marshall held that the Court could issue the order under their appellate jurisdiction, but Marbury would first have to refile the case in a lower court. Marbury never filed, so he never received his commission.Case Citation:Marbury v. Madison, 5 US 137 (1803)


Marbury v. Madison was an ingenious decision because it?

Marbury vs Madison was an ingenious decision. Marbury vs Madison was the first case of judicial review that voided the act of congress.


What action did William Marbury take to get Jefferson and Madison to deliver his commission?

William Marbury brought suit to secure his position as a Justice of the Peace in Washington D.C. The appointment was one of the last minute "Midnight Judges" assignments made in the waning hours of the Adams' administration pursuant to the Organic Act of 1801 (not to be confused with the Judiciary Act of 1801, which reorganized the federal courts and added sixteen new circuit judges).Specifically, Marbury wanted the Supreme Court to issue a "Writ of Mandamus" (a judicial order compelling a government official to carry out the duties of his office) to Jefferson's Secretary of State James Madison. Marbury wanted Madison to deliver his commission so he could take office.Chief Justice John Marshall (Jefferson's second cousin) ruled that, while Marbury's appointment was legal, the Supreme Court lacked original jurisdiction over the case, preventing them from ordering the executive branch to do anything. Marshall told Marbury he would first have to pursue the case in a lower court, then petition the US Supreme Court under its appellate jurisdiction if his grievances weren't addressed.Marshall also ruled that Section 13 of the Judiciary Act of 1789, passed under George Washington, was unconstitutional. By declaring an Act of Congress unconstitutional, Chief Justice Marshall affirmed the court's right of "judical review."Marbury did not get his job.Case Citation:Marbury v. Madison, 5 US 137 (1803)For more information on Marbury v. Madison, see Related Questions, below.

Related questions

Did William Marbury ever get the commission that Marbury v Madison said he had a right to?

No. In the opinion of the Court, Marshall declared Marbury was entitled to his commission, but that the Supreme Court didn't have original jurisdiction to issue the writ of mandamus Marbury requested. Marshall explicitly stated Marbury would have to refile his case in a lower court first, then appeal to the Supreme Court if he failed to get relief at that level. Marbury never refiled his case.Case Citation:Marbury v. Madison, 5 US 137 (1803)For more information, see Related Questions, below.


What was the name of the supreme court case of marbury vs Madison?

marbury vs. Madison


What famous case did the US Supreme Court hear in 1803?

Marbury v. Madison, 5 US 137 (1803)In Marbury v. Madison, the Supreme Court declared Section 13 of the the Judiciary Act of 1789 unconstitutional because Congress had attempted to give the Court original jurisdiction over writs of mandamus against officials of the US government, an authority John Marshall claimed was not conveyed by Article III of the Constitution.


In Marbury v. Madison did Marbury have a right to the office of Justice of the Peace?

According to Chief Justice John Marshall, yes. All the proper steps had been taken to secure Marbury's commission under former President John Adams. The only step that had not been completed before the administration changed was delivery of the documents, which then-Secretary of State John Marshall assumed incoming Secretary of State James Madison would take care of as a matter of course.Marshall didn't foresee Madison's delay in reaching Washington, nor Jefferson's intervention in the commissions' distribution. Nevertheless, all the legal steps had been completed correctly, and the commissions completed during Adams' administration.Marshall ruled that, while Marbury and the other plaintiffs were legally entitled to their positions as justices of the peace, the Supreme Court lacked authority to grant the writ of mandamus (court order compelling Madison complete delivery) under their original (trial) jurisdiction. Marshall held that the Court could issue the order under their appellate jurisdiction, but Marbury would first have to refile the case in a lower court. Marbury never filed, so he never received his commission.Case Citation:Marbury v. Madison, 5 US 137 (1803)


Marbury v. Madison was an ingenious decision because it?

Marbury vs Madison was an ingenious decision. Marbury vs Madison was the first case of judicial review that voided the act of congress.


What precedent did Marbury vs. Madison set?

Marbury vs. Madison established the precedent of judicial review. Marbury vs. Madison was heard in 1803 before the US Supreme court.


What did the Marbury v. Madison case established?

Marbury v. Madison established the practice of judicial review.


How do you use Marbury vs. Madison in a sentence?

Marbury vs, Madison was a famous American legal case in 1803.


What action did William Marbury take to get Jefferson and Madison to deliver his commission?

William Marbury brought suit to secure his position as a Justice of the Peace in Washington D.C. The appointment was one of the last minute "Midnight Judges" assignments made in the waning hours of the Adams' administration pursuant to the Organic Act of 1801 (not to be confused with the Judiciary Act of 1801, which reorganized the federal courts and added sixteen new circuit judges).Specifically, Marbury wanted the Supreme Court to issue a "Writ of Mandamus" (a judicial order compelling a government official to carry out the duties of his office) to Jefferson's Secretary of State James Madison. Marbury wanted Madison to deliver his commission so he could take office.Chief Justice John Marshall (Jefferson's second cousin) ruled that, while Marbury's appointment was legal, the Supreme Court lacked original jurisdiction over the case, preventing them from ordering the executive branch to do anything. Marshall told Marbury he would first have to pursue the case in a lower court, then petition the US Supreme Court under its appellate jurisdiction if his grievances weren't addressed.Marshall also ruled that Section 13 of the Judiciary Act of 1789, passed under George Washington, was unconstitutional. By declaring an Act of Congress unconstitutional, Chief Justice Marshall affirmed the court's right of "judical review."Marbury did not get his job.Case Citation:Marbury v. Madison, 5 US 137 (1803)For more information on Marbury v. Madison, see Related Questions, below.


Did William Marbury of Madison Vs Marbury fame have children?

Yes.


What is marburys full name in marbury vs madison?

William Marbury


In the US Supreme Court's opinion was Marbury entitled to his appointment?

Yes. In the opinion of the Court, Marshall declared Marbury was entitled to his commission, but that the Supreme Court didn't have original jurisdiction to issue the writ of mandamus Marbury requested. Marshall explicitly stated Marbury would have to refile his case in a lower court first, then appeal to the Supreme Court if he failed to get relief at that level. Marbury never refiled his case.Case Citation:Marbury v. Madison, 5 US 137 (1803)For more information, see Related Questions, below.