Best Answer

The Ninth and Tenth Amendments do not guarantee rights and thus there is an ongoing debate about the meaning of these amendments. The meanings of these amendments are quite ambigous because of the language and there are consequently numerous interpretations. For example, the Tenth amendment was designed to reserve powers to the states and two theories about this amendment were that it states the nature of American federalism but adds nothing to the Constitution as originally ratified and that it protects the powers of the states against national government.

User Avatar

Wiki User

13y ago
This answer is:
User Avatar

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: Why has it been difficult to resolve the meanings of the second third ninth and tenth amendments in the US Constitution?
Write your answer...
Still have questions?
magnify glass
Continue Learning about American Government

How did the resolve the Constitution when it did not have Civil liberties?

Civil liberties were added, in the form of the Bill of Rights.

How did the ratification of the Constitution remedy the economic problems of the US after the revolution and resolve the crisis of where political authority ultimately rested?

you must go to scc...

Why was it so difficult for the Framers to reach agreement about how to resolve their conflicts. Is it different today?

The Framers came from different states which caused them to have different opinions.

How did the constitution of 1917 try to resolve some of the problems that started the revolution?

It addressed land, religion, and labor it permitted the break up of large estates and placed restriction on foreigners owning land it allowed nationalization set a minimum wage and protected the right to strike

How did the US Constitution overcome the weaknesses of the Articles of Confederation and provide for the organization of the new government?

The Articles of Confederation had several weaknesses. As a result, a new plan of government, the Constitution, was written to clear up the weaknesses. Under the Articles of Confederation, there were many things the federal government couldn't do. It couldn't tax, make trade treaties, resolve disputes between states, keep order, and pay its debts. To help solve these issues, the writers of the Constitution created a federal government with three branches. Each branch had distinct powers to carry out its responsibilities. Additionally, the government had the ability to create an army. This army could be used to keep order at home as well as fight wars with other countries if needed. The Articles of Confederation can't be criticized for being a weak government because it was set up to be a weak government. However, the Constitution was much better, in part because the writers of the Constitution learned from the past mistakes that were made. They also included an amendment process to correct future problems that might arise. The Constitution was written, in part, to correct the mistakes and resolve the issues that existed in the Articles of Confederation.

Related questions

Why was the representation was such a difficult issue to resolve?

Representation was such a difficult issue to resolve because it consisted all legislation.

What do you think representation was such a difficult issue resolve?

Representation was such a difficult issue to resolve because it consisted all legislation.

How did US Constitution resolve slavery?

It didnt

How did the bill of rights resolve the ratification of the constitution?

The original idea was that since most states have their own Bill of Rights, they would not need to include one in the Constitution. However, to help appeal to other states so the Founding Fathers could get everyone to approve of it, they decided to add them as amendments, or formal changes to the constitution. 12 were proposed, but only 10 were passed. They resolved the issue by including these 10 amendments as the Bill of Rights.

Did the constitution resolve the weaknesses in the articles of confederation. explain your answer?


Did the constitution resolve the weakness in the articles of confederation explain your answer?


How did the resolve the Constitution when it did not have Civil liberties?

Civil liberties were added, in the form of the Bill of Rights.

The Supremacy Clause of the Constitution is meant to resolve conflicts between what?

national and state governments

The tenth amendment was added to the Constitution to resolve what topics of debate surrounding the development of the Constitution?

Balance between national and state government power

Who radify's amendments to the constitution?

The legislatures of 3/4 of the states (currently, that's 38 states). Alternatively, Congress (upon proposing the amendment) can stipulate that special conventions be held to vote on the proposed amendment in each state. In theory, if 2/3 of the state legislatures resolve to do so, they can force the Congress to convene a national constitutional convention to propose Amendments without the direct input of the Congress. That's never actually happened.

What is the main dutys of judicial branch?

To interpret the Constitution and resolve any disputes under the law.

Which of Erik Erikson's stages are most difficult to successfully resolve?

i really don't know.sorry