0
T and G didn't believe in ethics! It was all about who is stronger, who is more powerful. you can do anything if it meant getting what you want, your interest.
is this for a cultural studies paper?
al124
Their ideas of justice seem to be similar, however Glaucon does not truly believe this and says so in Plato's Republic line 358 c-d but Thrasymachus truly believes that justice is the advantage of the stronger, or that people rule for their own advantage and not for the ruled.
Dale
What else can I help you with?
What are the uses of ethical theories?
Ethical theories provide frameworks for analyzing and evaluating moral dilemmas, guiding decision-making in complex situations. They also help individuals to understand and justify their moral beliefs and actions, leading to more thoughtful and consistent ethical behavior. Additionally, ethical theories contribute to the development of ethical codes and principles that can be applied in various fields such as law, medicine, and business.
What is pre-conventional thinking?
Pre-conventional thinking is a stage of moral development where individuals base their ethical decisions on self-interest and avoiding punishment. This stage is characterized by a focus on rewards and consequences, with limited consideration for ethical principles or the needs of others.
What part of the paper helps you organize your ideas and shows the relationship among ideas in your writing?
An outline helps you organize your ideas and shows the relationship among ideas in your writing. It provides a structured framework for your thoughts and helps you see how different points are connected to each other in a logical way.
What are underlining ideas?
Underlying ideas refer to the foundational principles or concepts that form the basis of a particular topic, argument, or theory. These ideas are often not explicitly stated but can be identified through analysis and interpretation of the subject matter. Understanding underlying ideas can provide deeper insight and clarity on a given subject.
How does research support your ideas?
Research provides evidence and data to support assertions, helping to validate the credibility and accuracy of ideas. By referencing existing studies and findings, ideas are strengthened and have a solid foundation for discussion and analysis. Additionally, research allows for a deeper understanding of complex topics and can uncover new insights or perspectives.
Which virtue do Socrates and Thrasymachus try to define in Book I of The Republic?
In Book I of The Republic, Socrates and Thrasymachus try to define justice. Socrates argues that justice is inherently good and involves being virtuous and ethical, while Thrasymachus believes that justice is merely the interest of the stronger, advocating for self-interest and power dynamics in defining what is just.
Why might the position of the ancient Greek Thrasymachus concerning government and political systems be distorted?
The consensus among political historians regarding the possibility that the ideas of ancient Greek Thrasymachus may be distorted is because of the source of the information about him. Only in Plato's Republic do we hear about ideas that take a different slant on politics and government. As these ideas conflicted with Plato's, the possibility of distortion is clear.
What is the relationship between Socrates and Glaucon?
Glaucon and Palto's were brothers and both were Sacrates' students. ♥mya
Who is glaucon?
In philosophy, Glaucon is a character in Plato's "Republic." He is the brother of Plato and a key figure in the dialogue that discusses justice and the nature of the ideal state. Glaucon represents the perspective of someone who questions the nature of justice and seeks to understand its implications.
What was Plato's brother's name?
Plato's brother's name was Glaucon. He was one of Plato's siblings and a character in Plato's famous work, "The Republic."
What is the relationship between Plato Socrates and glaucon?
Plato was a student of Socrates, and Glaucon was Plato's older brother. Socrates was known for his philosophical teachings, which heavily influenced Plato's own works. Glaucon is mentioned in Plato's dialogues, such as "The Republic," where he participates in philosophical discussions.
How does Socrates refute Thrasymachus' definition of justice?
Socrates refutes Thrasymachus' definition of justice by arguing that true justice is not just the advantage of the stronger, as Thrasymachus claims, but rather a virtue that benefits all members of society. Socrates believes that justice is about doing what is right and fair, even if it may not always benefit the powerful.
What were the main points of contention between Socrates and Thrasymachus in their debate on justice in Plato's "Republic"?
Socrates and Thrasymachus disagreed on the nature of justice. Thrasymachus believed that justice is the advantage of the stronger, while Socrates argued that justice is inherently good and beneficial for all individuals. Their debate centered around whether justice is a form of power or a moral virtue that promotes the common good.
Which one of the following is one of the three important ideas of ethical responsibility?
One of the three ideas is explained in the following statement:
What were Plato's kids name?
His sons names are Adeimantus, and Glaucon. His daughters name is Potone
How many brothers and sisters did Plato have?
he had 1 brother
How does Glaucon describe the difference between appearing just and being just?
Glaucon argues that appearing just means obeying the laws and social norms for the sake of reputation or rewards, without truly believing in justice. Being just, on the other hand, involves internalizing and practicing justice for its own sake, even when no one is watching or rewarding you. He believes that true justice comes from within, not just from outward appearances.
