People who take a marble cake view of federalism believe that the responsibilities and powers of different levels of government—federal, state, and local—are intertwined and overlapping, much like the swirled layers of a marble cake. This perspective contrasts with the "layer cake" view, which sees federalism as a clear separation of powers among the different government levels. Proponents of the marble cake model argue that cooperation and collaboration among governments are essential for addressing complex policy issues effectively. This approach reflects the dynamic and interconnected nature of governance in a federal system.
cooperative federalism
The three eras of federalism are dual federalism (layer cake), cooperative federalism (marble), and new federalism.
Morton Grodzins' well-known for his comparisons of dual federalism to a layer cake and cooperative federalism to a marble cake.
The cake examples. There is a layered cake (Which represents dual federalism) and the marble cake (Which represents cooperative federalism).
The cakes refer to the different types of federalism. The main concern is the sharing or separation of powers and the extent to which the State and Federal governments cooperate or compete. They are as follows Layer Cake--Dual Federalism--1789 to 1860 Marble Cake--Cooperative Federalism-- 1930 to 1960 Pound Cake--Co-optive federalism-- 1960 to 1980 Crumble Cake--Competitive Federalism-- 1980 till Present
In a federalist government, power is divided between a central government and regional, such as state governments, or sub-divisional governments, such as city or county governments. Marble Cake Federalism, also called cooperative federalism, is a type in which powers, resources, and programs are intermingled between the different levels of government.
One of the examples is income tax, because national,state and local government can control it.
duel federalism is compared to a layer cake
The main difference between dual and cooperative federalism lies in the relationship and responsibilities between national and state governments. In dual federalism, often referred to as "layer cake" federalism, the powers and responsibilities of each level of government are distinctly separated, with limited interaction. In contrast, cooperative federalism, or "marble cake" federalism, emphasizes collaboration and overlapping responsibilities between national and state governments, where they work together to address complex issues and implement policies.
Federalism is an ideology based on how much power the federal (national) level of government should have. There are two main schools of thought. One is dual federalism (also known as layer cake federalism). Under dual federalizm, state and national government both have their own set of powers and should not interfere with each other's business. The other, cooperative federalism (or marble cake federalism), is based on the idea that both levels of government should work together. Take for example the New Deal.
layer cake federalism
Dual Federalism or Layered-cake federalism