answersLogoWhite

0

Mendel's laws deal with the transmission of genes between individuals. Evolution deals with changes in gene frequencies within and between populations.Population genetics, which mathematically analyzes how gene frequencies change over time in populations, is the backbone of evolutionary genetics, and it is based on Mendelian genetics being the transmission mechanism for individuals. So, the statement that Mendel's work "raises great obstacles" to evolutionary theory is simply ignorant and misleading.

Mendelian genetics support evolutionary theory in every way.

Actually, it doesn't. Darwin was unaware of Mendel's theory when he wrote his theory of Evolution (even though they lived at the same time), and because of the strong belief in Darwin's ideas it was not until the early 20'th century that the importance of the Mendelian theory was realized.

The Mendelian theory - because it showed that genes are own entities - raises great obstacles for the Darwinian theory. Natural selection operates on the organism level, rather than the gene level (the whole organism dies, if only one single fatal mutation occurs), which will mean that all the "good" mutations that need to add up during long time will get lost due only to a small number of fatal mutations, which makes it even more impossible for natural selection to give rise to something new which needs adding up of "good mutations".

The concept of "good mutations" - mutations that will be good only when many such mutations have been added together - is itself an erroneous way of thinking, because it builds on teleological reasoning (things get their "meaning" only after something has happened and you see the result) rather than causal reasoning ("cause gives effect"). Teleological reasoning is not rational in a naturalistic framework, because the only thing there is in such a framework is "cause gives effect".
There are alternate versions of a gene.

User Avatar

Wiki User

9y ago

What else can I help you with?

Related Questions

How did the idea of artificial selection contributed to Darwins ideas on natural selection?

00ss9q


Which is not of Darwin's theory of natural selection?

which is not part of darwins theory of natural selction


What book did he write about natural selection?

Darwins theory of evolution :)


What of Mendels conclusions is a necessary foundation for Darwins theory of natural selection?

Mendel's conclusion on the segregation and independent assortment of traits laid the groundwork for Darwin's theory of natural selection by providing a mechanism for how variation is passed down from one generation to the next. This understanding of how traits are inherited allowed Darwin to propose that natural selection acts on this variation to drive the evolution of populations.


What is the significance of the fourth step in Darwins theory of natural selection?

Survival of the fittest


How does Darwins theory of natural selection explain how the modern giraffe evolved from short-necked amcestors?

please answer


The weak died and the strong survives?

Also known as Darwins theory of Natural Selection, as in survival of the fittest.


How does Mendel theory of inheritance support Darwins theory of natural selection?

By giving the theory a mechanism of inheritance. Particulate inheritance, where each parent contributes chromosomes ( Mendel dod not know what a chromosome was and called genes " factors " ) that contain separate alleles that contribute to the progeny's traits. Darwin's idea of " blending " inheritance was completely wrong.


Which is not one of darwins four main ideas of natural selection?

Abiogenesis, or more commonly known as the origin of life itself, is not part of Darwin's theory of evolution.


What well known process was important when developing both mendels and Darwin's ideas?

The process of natural selection was important in developing both Mendel's and Darwin's ideas. Darwin's theory of evolution by natural selection explained how species change over time through the process of natural selection, while Mendel's laws of inheritance provided a mechanism for the transmission of traits from one generation to the next. Together, these ideas formed the foundation of modern evolutionary biology.


What was Darwins process of evolution called?

Darwin's process of evolution was called natural selection. This process involves the survival and reproduction of individuals with advantageous traits for their environment, leading to gradual changes in a population over time.


Is inheritance a requirement for natural selection?

Yes it does. Without variance in the organisms genome, that gives variance to the phenotype, there would be nothing for natural selection to select from.