answersLogoWhite

0

Yes, No and Maybe:

The stated intention of the Philadelphia Convention was to discuss and try to correct flaws in the Articles of Confederation. They certainly did that. Yes, some of the delegates may have gone there with no intention of repairing a flawed document (the Band Aid approach) and fully intending to create a new and stronger central government (the Major Surgery approach). As radical as big change may have seemed it quickly became apparent that something on a grander scale was needed to unite all of these former British Colonies. No, they did study and discuss the flaws in the Articles of Confederation and then they resolved to move beyond the fixer-upper approach. Maybe they went beyond the set guidelines of the Convention's limited agenda. Big ideas can sometimes evolve into grand documents like the United States Constitution.

User Avatar

Wiki User

15y ago

What else can I help you with?

Related Questions

Why did they call a meeting?

what was the meeting in Philadelphia call


Who suggested that a meeting be held in Philadelphia?

Alexander Hamilton suggested that another meeting to be held in Philadelphia.


What momentous decision did the Framers make at the beginning of the Philadelphia Convention?

That they were, infact, meeting to create a new Government for the United States."Resolved,....that a national Government ought to be established consisting of a supreme Legislative, Executive and Judiciary."


Which city did the Virginia assembly schedule a meeting to revise the articles of confederation?

The meeting was scheduled in Philadelphia.


What was the original purpose for calling a meeting in Philadelphia in 1787?

so, they could revise the articles of confederation


Why was the Meeting at Philadelphia called?

constitutional convection


In which city did the Virginia assembly schedule a meeting to revise the Articles of the Confederation?

The meeting was scheduled in Philadelphia.


What was the city and state of the meeting of the articles of confederation?

Philadelphia


What is the name of the meeting in 1787 in philadelphia?

Constitutional Convention


Is it true the original independence hall building is in Philadelphia?

Yes, the original Independence Hall building is located in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. It was completed in 1753 and served as the meeting place for the Second Continental Congress and the Constitutional Convention. It is also where the Declaration of Independence and the U.S. Constitution were debated and adopted. Today, it is a UNESCO World Heritage Site and a symbol of American democracy.


What is the name given to the meeting called to discuss making changes to the articles of confederation?

Continental Congress ordered the meeting of the Philadelphia Convention in 1787. the Philadelphia Convention produced the constitution.


Why did the founders disregard their original purpose for meeting in philadelphia?

The founders originally convened in Philadelphia to address issues with the Articles of Confederation, focusing on amending the existing framework. However, as discussions progressed, they recognized the inadequacy of the Articles to govern effectively and the need for a stronger centralized government. This shift in perspective led them to draft a new Constitution instead of merely revising the old one, prioritizing a more robust federal structure to address the challenges facing the nation. Ultimately, their vision evolved from mere amendments to creating a foundational document for a unified republic.