The Nehru Report of 1928, which was an attempt to outline constitutional reforms in British India, included several prominent Muslim members. Notable Muslim figures involved were Mohammad Ali Jinnah, who later became a key leader of the All-India Muslim League, and Aga Khan, who was the spiritual leader of the Ismaili community. Other Muslim leaders who participated included Maulana Mohammad Ali and his brother Shaukat Ali. Their involvement highlighted the complexities of Muslim representation in the Indian political landscape during that period.
The Nehru Report, drafted in 1928, aimed to outline constitutional reforms for India. It proposed a dominion status for India within the British Empire, with provisions for a parliamentary system, universal suffrage, and responsible government. Importantly, it recommended a bicameral legislature and a significant expansion of provincial autonomy. However, it did not accommodate separate electorates for Muslims, leading to widespread dissatisfaction among Muslim leaders.
Nehru report was presented in opposition to Simon Commission. This presented proposals which should be granted them (Indians) as concessions as decided in MC reforms in July in 1919. this was purely Hindu dominated proposal with no rights to Muslims.
The Nehru Report, presented in 1928, was a proposal for constitutional reforms in British India, drafted by a committee led by Motilal Nehru, the father of Jawaharlal Nehru. It aimed to address Indian demands for greater self-governance and included recommendations for a dominion status for India, a parliamentary system, and equal representation for all communities. The report was significant as it marked an early effort by Indian nationalists to articulate their political aspirations and was met with mixed reactions from various political groups, leading to further discussions about India's future governance.
The Nehru Report concentrated a lot of power in the federal government. Muslims as a national minority would not have a large amount of power to control federal policy. Correspondingly, the Muslims demanded an increase in provincial power relative to the federal authority if they were to be part of federal India project.
Dr.B.R.Ambedkar, Pandit Jawaharlal Nehru ,Sardar Vallabhai Patel, etc.
because many Muslims felt that they were being asked to make too many sacrifices.
Hindu
He was a parsi, so therefore not a muslimNo. Feroze Gandhi was a Parsi or Zoroastrian.
28 august 1928
The Nehru Report, drafted in 1928, aimed to outline constitutional reforms for India. It proposed a dominion status for India within the British Empire, with provisions for a parliamentary system, universal suffrage, and responsible government. Importantly, it recommended a bicameral legislature and a significant expansion of provincial autonomy. However, it did not accommodate separate electorates for Muslims, leading to widespread dissatisfaction among Muslim leaders.
Kyo K WO BHARWA THA
56tyuhrdgh
The main difference between the nehru report and jinnah points was that Nehru report focused on addressing the issues related to hindus whereas jinnah points focused on addressing the issues related to muslims. Jinnah points demanded separate rights for muslims which were left ignored in Nehru report. Jinnah demanded the separate electorate rights for muslims. He demanded that muslim majority areas should be given a separate status Jinnah suggested that sindh should be separated from the Bombay presidency. Hence Jinnah points were for the protection of rights of muslims and Nehru report failed to address the rights of muslims. A comparison of the Nehru Report with the Quaid-e-Azam's fourteen points shows that the political gap between the Muslims and the Hindus had really widened. Fourteen points of Quaid-e-Azam became principles for the Muslims of India. The importance of these points can be judged by the fact that these points were presented in the Round Table Conference of 1930. As a result, these points became the demands of the Muslims and greatly influenced the Muslims thinking for the next two decades till the establishment of Pakistan in 1947
Nehru report was presented in opposition to Simon Commission. This presented proposals which should be granted them (Indians) as concessions as decided in MC reforms in July in 1919. this was purely Hindu dominated proposal with no rights to Muslims.
Nehru report was presented in opposition to Simon Commission. This presented proposals which should be granted them (Indians) as concessions as decided in MC reforms in July in 1919. this was purely Hindu dominated proposal with no rights to Muslims.
The Nehru Report, presented in 1928, was a proposal for constitutional reforms in British India, drafted by a committee led by Motilal Nehru, the father of Jawaharlal Nehru. It aimed to address Indian demands for greater self-governance and included recommendations for a dominion status for India, a parliamentary system, and equal representation for all communities. The report was significant as it marked an early effort by Indian nationalists to articulate their political aspirations and was met with mixed reactions from various political groups, leading to further discussions about India's future governance.
All the points were rejected by the Quaid