0
Which posed a greater threat to the Catholic Church the Protestant Reformation or the Scientific Reformation and why?
Let:s get things straight. ...---... SOS< the church was never hostile to communications technology- with the possible exception of Television content, as these devices could - among other uses- spread the gospel. Look at the Gutenberg Bible, the first book printed by mechanical means. the first telegraph message was- by Mr. Morse himself- What Hath God Wrought? There was no theological objection to telegraphy, and later telephony- radio, etc. in fact there is a kind of manifest destiny attitude towards communications technology in, say Battle hymn of the Republic and much later- Send the Light! ( a spiritual) the spiritual writer was correct about the undamped wave of radio-telegraphy (called the restless wave in the song) so it goes- what fueled the anti-science thing- was EVOLUTION.
.
Catholic AnswerI would agree with the above answer - let's get things straight: First of all, nothing really poses a threat to the Catholic Church, as such, as the Catholic Church is the Mystical Body of Christ, and the thought of anything posing a threat to God Almighty is kind of ludicrous..
Second, if you are talking about "posing a threat" as removing people from the possibility of salvation because you are causing them to doubt the Church (i.e. doubt God's Word), then the scientific reformation and the protestant revolt are intimately connected. The scientific reformation was primarily based on Catholic scientists and Catholic research. However, it was used by those who had a problem with the Church, i.e. didn't want to live with her moral demands and used the scientific reformation in a way that it shouldn't have been, twisted things and used them against the Church. For a better understanding of these two movements, what contributed to them, and what results came out of them, I would recommend three small books by Diane Moczar, a history professor at Northern Virginia Community College:
Seven Lies About Catholic History
Ten Dates Every Catholic Should Know
Catholic History from the Catacombs to the Reformation.
These three books will give you an excellent overview of the development of history and the high and low points of civilization, particularly as it relates to the Church.
What else can I help you with?
What are some positive effects of the Protestant Reformation?
THE CONSEQUENCES OF THE REFORMATION -Common People now had the Bible in their own language -Catholicism was now not the only Christian sect -True Christianity made a comeback in a big way -Sola Fide- Salvation by Faith -Popes now only had limited power because of the peace of augsburg
What were the goals of the Catholic Reformation and did it succeed?
Catholic Answer It was the Catholic response to the protestant reformation (also called the Counter-Reformation), although the Catholic Reform actually started before the protestant revolt. It involved greater emphasis on the central power of the papacy, the clarification of a number of core doctrines and the refutation of Protestant beliefs at the Council of Trent, and the growth of popular religious movements at grass-roots levels such as the Society of Jesus to promote Catholic doctrines and root out heretical beliefs. To a large extent it did succeed but it failed in bringing many of those back to the church who had been lost, and the generations that followed who have been denied access to the sacraments.from A Catholic Dictionary, edited by Donald Attwater, Second edition, revised 1957The Counter-Reformation is the name given to the Catholic movement of reform and activity which lasted for about one hundred years from the beginning of the Council of Trent (q.v., 1545), and was the belated answer to the threatening confusion and increasing attacks of the previous years. It was the work principally of the Popes St. Pius V and Gregory XIII and the Council itself in the sphere of authority, of SS. Philip Neri and Charles Borromeo in the reform of the clergy and of life, of St. Ignatius and the Jesuits in apostolic activity of St. Francis Xavier in foreign missions, and of St. Teresa in the purely contemplative life which lies behind them all. But these were not the only names nor was it a movement of a few only; the whole Church emerged from the 15th century purified and revivified. On the other hand, it was a reformation rather than a restoration; the unity of western Christendom was destroyed; the Church militant (those still on earth) led by the Company of Jesus adopted offence as the best means of defence and, though she gained as much as she lost in some sense, the Church did not recover the exercise of her former spiritual supremacy in actuality.
How do Erasmus and Jan Hus relate?
They were both reformers of 15th Century Europe who sought to change the corrupt practices of the Catholic Church. Erasmus was a humanist, who wished to educate people in the classics for the purpose of gaining a greater knowledge of God. Jan Hus was a Eucharist, famously burned at the stake in 1415. Both Erasmus and Jan Hus were important predecessors to what would eventually become the Protestant Reformation in the 16th Century.
What are the protestant beliefs?
Protestants have many different beliefs. When Martin Luther broke with the Roman Catholic Church he summarized his differences as only Grace, only Faith, and only Scripture. He continued to accept the Apostles Creed, the Nicene Creed, and many other Christian teachings used by the Roman Catholics. Different protestant groups have different beliefs. The differences in procedures are usually much greater than the differences in doctrine.
Martin Luther was justified in his criticisms of the pope?
Martin Luther was justified in his criticisms of the pope, particularly regarding the sale of indulgences and the perceived corruption within the Catholic Church. He believed that these practices undermined the core tenets of Christianity and the authority of scripture. By challenging the pope's authority, Luther sought to return to a more authentic faith based on personal belief and biblical teachings, which resonated with many who felt disillusioned by the Church's practices. His actions ultimately sparked the Protestant Reformation, promoting a movement toward religious reform and greater individual interpretation of faith.
What catholic reformation?
It was the Catholic response to the Protestant reformation (also called the Counter-Reformation). It involved greater emphasis on the central power of the papacy, the clarification of a number of core doctrines and the refutation of Protestant beliefs at the Council of Trent, and the growth of popular religious movements at grass-roots levels such as the Society of Jesus to promote Catholic doctrines and root out heretical beliefs.
Who had a greater impact on the Protestant Reformation, Martin Luther or John Calvin"?
Both Martin Luther and John Calvin had significant impacts on the Protestant Reformation, but Martin Luther is generally considered to have had a greater influence due to his role in sparking the movement with his Ninety-Five Theses and his emphasis on justification by faith alone. John Calvin's teachings further developed Protestant theology, but Luther's initial actions were pivotal in shaping the Reformation.
What are some positive effects of the Protestant Reformation?
THE CONSEQUENCES OF THE REFORMATION -Common People now had the Bible in their own language -Catholicism was now not the only Christian sect -True Christianity made a comeback in a big way -Sola Fide- Salvation by Faith -Popes now only had limited power because of the peace of augsburg
Who was responsible for bringing about the Protestant Reformation?
In one sense, Pope Leo X and Prierias, Master of the Papal Palace, were responsible for bringing about the Protestant Reformation, because Leo greatly increased the sale in Indulgences and Prierias declared any challenge to the sale of indulgences heretical. This led inevitably to a confrontation in which neither side could compromise.In another sense, Martin Luther was directly and transparently responsible for bringing about the Protestant Reformation, because he saw corruption and the potential for greater corruption in the Church and sought to regulate the sale of Indulgences. This struck at the heart of the papal lifestyle and eventually resulted in his excommunication. Luther began to criticise other aspects of Catholic doctrine and practice, until only a complete break with Rome was possible.
Why are Catholic Churches more rich and posh than a protestant church?
Catholic Churches are built for one reason, and one reason only, to give greater glory to God, and to be a worthy home for Him, especially in the Eucharist, which is reserved in every Catholic Church. Protestant churches do not have Jesus in the Eucharist and thus are no more than meeting houses where people gather for prayer, the entire orientation is different.
What were the goals of the Catholic Reformation and did it succeed?
Catholic Answer It was the Catholic response to the protestant reformation (also called the Counter-Reformation), although the Catholic Reform actually started before the protestant revolt. It involved greater emphasis on the central power of the papacy, the clarification of a number of core doctrines and the refutation of Protestant beliefs at the Council of Trent, and the growth of popular religious movements at grass-roots levels such as the Society of Jesus to promote Catholic doctrines and root out heretical beliefs. To a large extent it did succeed but it failed in bringing many of those back to the church who had been lost, and the generations that followed who have been denied access to the sacraments.from A Catholic Dictionary, edited by Donald Attwater, Second edition, revised 1957The Counter-Reformation is the name given to the Catholic movement of reform and activity which lasted for about one hundred years from the beginning of the Council of Trent (q.v., 1545), and was the belated answer to the threatening confusion and increasing attacks of the previous years. It was the work principally of the Popes St. Pius V and Gregory XIII and the Council itself in the sphere of authority, of SS. Philip Neri and Charles Borromeo in the reform of the clergy and of life, of St. Ignatius and the Jesuits in apostolic activity of St. Francis Xavier in foreign missions, and of St. Teresa in the purely contemplative life which lies behind them all. But these were not the only names nor was it a movement of a few only; the whole Church emerged from the 15th century purified and revivified. On the other hand, it was a reformation rather than a restoration; the unity of western Christendom was destroyed; the Church militant (those still on earth) led by the Company of Jesus adopted offence as the best means of defence and, though she gained as much as she lost in some sense, the Church did not recover the exercise of her former spiritual supremacy in actuality.
Why did Henry Vlll want parliament to dissolve England ties to the Catholic Church?
Henry VIII sought to dissolve England's ties to the Catholic Church primarily to secure an annulment of his marriage to Catherine of Aragon, which the Pope refused to grant. By breaking away from the Catholic Church and establishing the Church of England, he could assume greater control over religious matters and ensure his desired marriage to Anne Boleyn. Additionally, this move allowed him to seize church lands and wealth, strengthening his financial and political power. Ultimately, it was a significant step in the broader Protestant Reformation in England.
How do Erasmus and Jan Hus relate?
They were both reformers of 15th Century Europe who sought to change the corrupt practices of the Catholic Church. Erasmus was a humanist, who wished to educate people in the classics for the purpose of gaining a greater knowledge of God. Jan Hus was a Eucharist, famously burned at the stake in 1415. Both Erasmus and Jan Hus were important predecessors to what would eventually become the Protestant Reformation in the 16th Century.
What did the catholic church think about the scientific revolution?
The Catholic Church initially viewed the scientific revolution with caution and suspicion due to its challenge to traditional beliefs. However, some early scientists, like Galileo, faced opposition from the Church when their ideas conflicted with religious teachings. Over time, the Church's stance evolved, leading to greater acceptance and incorporating scientific advancements into its worldview.
What was the major goal of the catholic reformation?
This is what Catholic Reformation Means: Restatement of traditional Catholic beliefs in response to Protestant Reformation (16th century); established councils that revived Catholic doctrine and refuted Protestant beliefs..Roman Catholic AnswerIn addition to the above answer, which is very good, it attempted to re-convert the new protestants and to reinvigorate the religious life, see the article below: fromModern Catholic Dictionary by John A. Hardon, S.J. Doubleday & Co., Inc. Garden City, NY 1980A period of Catholic revival from 1522 to about 1648, better know as the Catholic Reform. It was an effort to stem the tide of Protestantism by genuine reform within the Catholic Church. There were political movements pressured by civil rules, and ecclesiastical movements carried out by churchmen in an attempt to restore genuine Catholic life by establishing new religious orders such as the Society of Jesus and restoring old orders to their original observances, such as the Carmelites under St. Teresa of Avila (1515-98). The main factors responsible for the Counter Reformation, however, were the papacy and the council of Trent (1545-63). Among church leaders St. Charles Borromeo (1538-84), Archbishop of Milan, enforced the reforms decreed by the council, and St. Francis de Sales of Geneva (1567-1622) spent his best energies in restoring genuine Catholic doctrine and piety. Among civil rulers sponsoring the needed reform were Philip II of Spain (1527-98) and Mary Tudor (1516-58), his wife, in England. Unfortunately this aspect of the reformation led to embitterment between England and Scotland, England and Spain, Poland and Sweden, and to almost two centuries of religious wars. As a result of the Counter Reformation, the Catholic Church became stronger in her institutional structure, more dedicated to the work of evangelization, and more influential in world affairs.
What broke down during reformation that opened the way for monarchs to assume greater control?
The Catholic Church's stranglehold on domestic politics in Europe was broken, allowing local leadership a much stronger role in governance.
What was the purpose of the Catholic reformation?
It was the Catholic response to the Protestant reformation (also called the Counter-Reformation). It involved greater emphasis on the central power of the papacy, the clarification of a number of core doctrines and the refutation of Protestant beliefs at the Council of Trent, and the growth of popular religious movements at grass-roots levels such as the Society of Jesus to promote Catholic doctrines and root out heretical beliefs.
