answersLogoWhite

0

A deposition is when the lawyers for one side or the other in the case subpoena a witness and depose him or her, asking him or her the exact same questions, under oath, and with a court reporter present, that they would ask him or her in trial.

Depositions usually happen in the law offices of one side or the other in the trial; and lawyers from both sides are present. Since depositions are done for the purpose of finding out what the opposing party's witnesses are going to say at trial, the deposing attorney is allowed to use cross-examining techniques and is not limited to the restrictions placed on direct examination. After all, the person being deposed is not the deposing attorney's witness unless the deposition has been called for the purpose of preserving the testimony of a witness whose health is in grave danger or who might be unavailable at trial for some reason. After the deposing attorney is finished, the other attorney is allowed to ask follow up questions to clarify answers of the witness. Those questions are not cross-examining questions; they are more in the nature of redirect examination questions.

Since there's no judge present, if either side objects to something, it's either noted for possible later ruling by the judge, or the deposition stops and the parties go before the judge to get a ruling, and then they resume.

In a criminal trial, the defendant cannot be subpoeanaed as a witness... either in a deposition, or at trial. However, if it's a civil case, then the defendant may not refuse to testify. S/he may not "remain silent."

However, if something the defendant might say, even in a civil trial, could somehow incriminate him/her, then s/he may assert his/her right against self-incrimination under the Fifth Amendment to the Constitution of the United States, and remain silent. Such doesn't usually go over very well, though, with the judge in a civil trial... especially if the witness is the civil defendant. A hearing would likely ensue, and the defendant may very well be ordered to testify... especially if the prosecutor gives the defendant what's called "use immunity," thereby eliminating any possibility of prosecuting the civil defendant for anything to which s/he testifies in either civil deposition or civil trial.

A defendant who "takes the fifth," as it's called, in a criminal trial, is another matter altogether. Usually, such is not even necessary since all parties know that the defendant need not testify in his own criminal trial, no matter what. Of course, if he wants to, he can; and if he does, and he hits a point in his testimony wherein his answer could further incriminate him, then, yes, he could "take the fifth." But, again, there'd be a hearing, then likely an offer of some kind of conditional use immunity, and the defendant may very well be ordered to testify. While judges are loathe to order criminal defendants to testify, once they deign to get on the witness stand, and start to so do, all bets can, in the judge's mind, be kinda' off.

Any witness, though, may, if s/he has a reasonable good faith belief that his/her answer will incriminate her -- whether in a civil or criminal deposition, or at civil or criminal trial -- invoke his/her rights under the Fifth Amendment, and so, then, remain silent. However, s/he had better not be lying about that reasonable good faith belief. It has to be real, and it has to be serious.

It can also, in most states, not be selective. A witness may typically not testify as to one thing, and then selectively "take the fifth" regarding other things. Usually, once the witness "takes the fifth," then his/her testimony is overwith. The exception can be grand jury testimony, which can, in some states, be selective.

User Avatar

Wiki User

12y ago

What else can I help you with?

Related Questions

Can you choose not to attend a Deposition?

If you have received a summons or subpoean to do so, no you cannot.


If you assault someone with a weapon and they choose to not press charges can the DA do it anyway even if the person involved wont testify?

If there is a witness who can testafy, then yes. Also if you made any statement saying you did, then they can.


Can a work colleque be an independent witness?

Yes, a work colleague can be an independent witness, but it often depends on the context and the nature of the situation. For legal or formal matters, such as investigations or disputes, their independence may be questioned if they have a close relationship with one of the parties involved. It's generally better to choose a witness who has no vested interest in the outcome to ensure objectivity.


is it a personal injury litigation if there are not any lawyers involved?

If you choose to pursue a personal injury suit, you are not required to use a lawyer, but most litigation does involve a lawyer because of the complicated procedure.


Can a witness choose to plead the fifth in a civil case to avoid self-incrimination?

Yes, a witness can choose to plead the Fifth Amendment in a civil case to avoid self-incrimination. This means they can refuse to answer questions that may potentially expose them to criminal liability.


Is jehovah's witness can choose a location for wedding ceremony other than the Kingdom Hall?

Yes, we can. :)


Does a witness need a lawyer when testifying in court?

A witness does not typically need a lawyer when testifying in court. Witnesses are usually called to provide their testimony and answer questions truthfully. However, in certain circumstances, a witness may choose to consult with a lawyer for guidance or representation.


What is the procedure of the sandwich?

1. Choose a bread. 2. Choose your condiments. 3. Choose your fillings. 4. Eat the sandwich cold. 5. Alternatively, grill/cook the sandwich.


A witness who refuses to testify after being granted immunity?

When a witness refuses to testify after being granted immunity, it can complicate legal proceedings. Immunity is intended to protect the witness from prosecution for the information they provide, but if they still choose not to cooperate, the court may hold them in contempt. This refusal can hinder the investigation or prosecution, and the legal system may explore alternative methods to compel testimony, such as issuing subpoenas or using other legal measures. Ultimately, the implications of such a refusal depend on the context and jurisdiction involved.


Can a relative witness the promissory note?

Yes, a relative can witness a promissory note as long as they are not a party to the agreement and do not have a financial interest in the transaction. However, it is generally recommended to choose a neutral third party as a witness to avoid any potential conflicts of interest or challenges to the validity of the document.


What factors does a surgeon consider in deciding which procedure to use in a bunionectomy?

Surgeons consider the angle of the bone misalignment, the condition of the bursa, and the strength of the bones when they choose which procedure to use.


Can a witness to a will inherit?

In most jurisdictions, a witness to a will cannot inherit from that will because they may be seen as having a conflict of interest. This is to prevent any perception of potential undue influence or coercion on the testator. It is advisable to choose neutral witnesses who are not beneficiaries of the will.