a nonpartisan commission that reviews the qualifications of applicants for judicial office
Another name for the merit selection of judges is the "Missouri Plan" or the "Judicial Merit Selection System." It is a method used to appoint judges based on their qualifications and experience rather than through political appointments or elections.
Benjamin Franklin's The Way to WealthThe people is the answer to the question"... I concluded at length, that the people were the best judges of my merit; for they ..."
In 2013, the criteria for selecting National Merit Scholars included high scores on the PSAT/NMSQT exam, academic performance, a recommendation from a school official, an essay, and participation in extracurricular activities.
Missouri
Missouri bar
The general conclusion on the differences between merit selection and elective systems for judges centers around accountability and qualifications. Merit selection emphasizes the appointment of judges based on qualifications and professional competence, often involving a nominating commission to ensure impartiality. In contrast, elective systems prioritize direct accountability to the electorate, allowing voters to choose judges, which can lead to concerns about political influence and campaign financing. Ultimately, the choice between these systems reflects a balance between judicial independence and public accountability.
it has developed into more of a merit-based system for selecting officals
the criminal justice system allows judges and prosecutors to treat each case on its own merit.
Many judges are state and federal judges, so perhaps their jurisdiction is extended beyond the county they are in. If a search warrant is presented to you by the police, you can be certain it has merit just as it stands.
Judges in Florida are selected 1 of 2 ways. The lower level judges are selected through a public election The higher level judges are selected through a merit selection. A merit selection is when the board comprises a list of possible judge selections and the governor of the state then picks one from that list. After the judge has served his/her first term (4 years) he/she must attend a retention hearing to see if they will continue to serve as the judge.
Larry Charles Berkson has written: 'A merit plan for selecting judges in Florida' -- subject(s): Judges, Selection and appointment 'A study of the U.S. Circuit Judge Nominating Commission' -- subject(s): Appointment, qualifications, tenure, Circuit courts, Judges, Selection and appointment, United States, United States Circuit Judge Nominating Commisson, United States. Circuit Judge Nominating Commisson 'National roster of women judges, 1980' -- subject(s): Directories, Women judges