Cases in equity are not eligible for a jury trial, where someone is suing for either an injunction or some similar as a matter of law and fairness - examples being things such as an injunction against a demolition, injunction against selling a disputed house to someone else, child custody cases, and so on. Also, cases where the dispute solely revolves questions of law rather than fact are not eligible for a jury trial.
In addition to cases in equity, cases in common law where the amount in controversy is $20 or less are not entitled to a jury, as per the Seventh Amendment to the US Constitution.
Every United States citizen is entitled to a trial by jury when being indicted of a crime. Each citizen also has the right to waive this kind of trial and have the case heard only by a judge.
The defendant can request a trial held only in front of a judge (bench trial) or trial held in front of a jury (jury trial). In some cases (capital crimes) the option is not offered and a trial by jury is mandatory.
Article 3, Section 2:"The trial of all crimes, except in cases of impeachment, shall be by jury." This means that every crime will be a trial by jury except for cases of impeachment.Impeach: to charge someone with a public offense
In certain cases you can request a trial in front of a judge only. This option is not available in the case of Capital Crimes.
In a criminal case, you are entitled to a jury trial if the potential punishment is serious. Recently, I believe the Supreme Court has defined this as any crime where the maximum punishment is 6 months or greater in jail. Generally, this includes all crimes, but there are some ordinance violations and petty crimes that aren't severe enough. In a civil matter, you are almost always entitled to a jury trial.
No, in any trial by jury the judge may determine it necessary to sequester the jury..
Because in the federal court system, District Courts are the lowest level of courts of original jurisdiction. Therefore, Constitutionally, defendants appearing for trial before District Courts are entitled to a trial by jury.
No. All federal circuit trial courts hear both jury and bench trials.
The option to a jury trial is called a "bench trial." This is where a judge hears the evidence and decides without a jury. In criminal cases, the defense almost always prefers a jury trial because you only have to convince one of the jury members to avoid a conviction. Judges may be seen as less susceptible to using sympathy for a "victim" to convict than a jury. Also, if the case is more about some complex legal issue than the facts, a judge is more likely to understand the defense and find a defendant not guilty. In civil cases, a non- jury trial is better for the party that believes the law is on their side, and the jury trial is better suited for the party that hopes to confuse the jury and win based on other factors. A final consideration is cost. Non-jury trials are much shorter and therefore less expensive.
Text of Seventh Amendment is as follows: "In Suits at common law, where the value in controversy shall exceed twenty dollars, the right of trial by jury shall be preserved, and no fact tried by a jury, shall be otherwise re-examined in any Court of the United States, than according to the rules of the common law."Important Note: The Seventh Amendment is not incorporated to the states, so the right to trial by jury in civil cases exists only in federal court.
In a bench trial, a judge serves as the sole decision-maker, evaluating the evidence and determining the verdict without a jury. This type of trial is often preferred for its efficiency and the judge's expertise in legal matters. The judge not only rules on the admissibility of evidence but also interprets the law and applies it to the facts of the case. Bench trials are common in civil cases and some criminal cases where the parties waive their right to a jury trial.
A trial that has no jury is called a bench trial. A defendant may choose to waive his right to a jury trial and have his case heard and decided by a judge only. See the link below for a simple description of this type of trial.