answersLogoWhite

0


Best Answer

By one perspective, the "pros" are that they're a great idea, the "cons" are that they are ignored in too many ways.

By a less radical perspective, the "pros" are that they're a great idea, the "cons" are that they are not wrote as fully detailed as we'd like.

For instance, was the right to bear arms really meant to be an absolute, including the right to have a nuclear missile in your back yard? Or less dramatically, was it meant so that you could have the same arms as a regular soldier in the Army?

When you are guaranteed the right to a jury trial - did they mean a 12 person jury that has to unanimously agree and with the right to nullify fully acknowledged? Or would a three person panel of professional jurors employed by the state and deciding by 2/3rds majority with no nullification allowed meet the requirement of the amendment?

Of course, it's not our founder's fault, these "cons". They were writing in plain English, it's two and a third centuries of lawyers "interpreting" that's made it unclear. One suspects that even if each amendment was 10 pages long, that the lawyers and legislators and justices would still find "excepts" and "what ifs" in it.

I guess then that the biggest "con" of all is that a piece paper can't make politicians honor it, no matter the oaths they swear.

User Avatar

Wiki User

14y ago
This answer is:
User Avatar

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: Pros and cons of first 10 amendments?
Write your answer...
Submit
Still have questions?
magnify glass
imp
Continue Learning about Law

What legal rights do you obtain at the age of 15?

1. You may be remanded to a remand centre or prison to await trial.2. If you are convicted of a criminal offence you can be fined up to £1000 and sentenced to detention.3. You can see a 15 category film or rent and buy a 15 category film.


What is the main idea of the US Bill of Rights?

The US Bill of Rights exists due to the decision of the framers of the constitution in 1783 to codify (make law) a specific list of the most important freedoms which must be safeguarded for the United States of America to begin its life as a constitutional democracy. Therefore, the first 10 amendments to the US Constitution became known as the US Bill of Rights.


What are the ten codes used by law enforcement in ottumwa wapello county Iowa?

10-1 Unable To Copy 10-44 Request Permission To Leave 10-2 Signals Good Patrol ____ For _____ 10-3 Stop Transmitting 10-45 Animal Carcass In Lane 10-4 Acknowledgement 10-46 Assist Motorist 10-5 Relay 10-47 Emergency Road Repair Needed 10-6 Busy-Stand By Unless Urgent 10-48 Traffic Standard Needs Repair 10-7 Out Of Service (give location 10-49 Traffic Lights Out and/or telephone number) 10-50 Accident---F,PI,PD 10-8 In Service 10-51 Wrecker Needed 10-9 Repeat 10-52 Ambulance Needed 10-10 Fight In Progress 10-53 Road Blocked 10-11 Dog Case 10-54 Livestock On Highway 10-12 Stand By (stop) 10-55 Intoxicated Driver 10-13 Weather & Road Report 10-56 Intoxicated Pedestrian 10-14 Report To Prowler 10-57 Hit & Run--F,PI,PD 10-15 Civil Disturbance 10-58 Direct Traffic 10-16 Domestic Trouble 10-59 Convoy Or Escort 10-17 Meet Complainant 10-60 Squad In Vicinity 10-18 Complete Assignment 10-61 Personnel In Area 10-19 Return To _____ 10-62 Reply To Message 10-20 Location 10-63 Prepare To Make Written Copy 10-21 Call ____ By Telephone 10-64 Message For Local Delivery 10-22 Disregard 10-65 Net Message Assignment 10-23 Arrived At Scene 10-66 Message Cancellation 10-24 Assignment Completed 10-67 Clear To Read Net Message 10-25 Report In Person To (meet)___ 10-68 Dispatch Information 10-26 Detaining Subject, Expedite 10-69 Message Received 10-27 Drivers License Information 10-70 Fire Alarm 1--To Check For Valid License 10-71 Advise Nature Of Fire (size, 2--To Check For Previous type, & contents of building) O.M.V.U.I Convictions 10-72 Report Progress On Fire 3--To Check For Age Or 10-73 Smoke Report Description Or Serial 10-74 Negative Number, Etc. 10-75 In Contact With 4--To Check Complete Driving 10-76 In Route Report 10-77 ETA (estimate time of arrival) 10-28 Vehicle Registration Info. 10-78 Needed Assistance 10-29 Check Records For Wanted 10-79 Notify 10-30 Illegal Use Of Records 10-82 Reserve Lodging 10-31 Crime In Progress 10-84 If Meeting___ Advise ETA 10-32 Man With Gun 10-85 Will Be Late 10-33 EMERGENCY 10-87 Pick Up Checks For Distribution 10-34 Riot 10-88 Advise Present Telephone Of ____ 10-35 Major Crime Alert 10-90 Bank Alarm 10-36 Correct Time 10-91 Unnecessary Use Of Radio 10-37 Investigate Suspicious Vehicle 10-93 Blockade 10-38 Stopping Suspicious Vehicle 10-94 Drag Racing (give us complete description) 10-96 Mental Subject 10-39 Urgent--Use Lights & Siren 10-98 Prison Or Jail Break 10-40 Silent Run-No Lights Or Siren 10-99 Records Indicate Wanted Or 10-41 Beginning Tour Of Duty Stolen 10-42 Ending Tour Of Duty 10-43 Information 10-200 Drugs


Which amendment is equal rights?

The Equal Rights Amendment (ERA) was written in 1921 and first introduced in Congress in 1923. It passed Congress in 1972, was not ratified during the 10-year period allowed.


What was the 9-10 ratio?

9:10