answersLogoWhite

0

Yes.

Try reading some of McClellan's letters to Lincoln. They reveal a lot. McClellan was all talk, no action.

User Avatar

Aliza Upton

Lvl 13
3y ago

Still curious? Ask our experts.

Chat with our AI personalities

FranFran
I've made my fair share of mistakes, and if I can help you avoid a few, I'd sure like to try.
Chat with Fran
EzraEzra
Faith is not about having all the answers, but learning to ask the right questions.
Chat with Ezra
BlakeBlake
As your older brother, I've been where you are—maybe not exactly, but close enough.
Chat with Blake

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: Was Lincoln decision to fire mcclellan a good one?
Write your answer...
Submit
Still have questions?
magnify glass
imp
Continue Learning about Military History

Why was mcclellan fired during the civil war?

He was fired after the Battle of Antietam. Lincoln decided McClellan was too slow to attack the enemy and he let General Lee slip away after the big battle. McClellan did prove to be a great organizer of the army and established some good principal on training.


What happened to Union Secretary of War Edwin Stanton?

Edward W. Stanton was US President Lincoln's second Secretary of War. He replaced Simon Cameron, who was not doing a good job and there was a question on his morality based on corruption rumors. Stanton had been a rival of Lincoln's for the 1860 Republican Party nominee. He played a major role in the war and his greatest enemy was Union General George B. McClellan. Stanton was a fierce politician and at one point sought to have McClellan court martialed.He was also a victim of the John Wilkes Booth conspiracy to kill Lincoln, Seward and Stanton. All but Lincoln survived.


Why was grant more effective than McClellan?

Grant was very different from McClellan. They were both excellent in different fields, but Grant was more effective...McClellan was an excellent planner and had much experience on the battlefield, the problem was that he wasn't a very good leader. He wasn't good at making decisions in a fast-paced battlefield, and often kept many soldiers to doing nothing at very important points of the war. Although McClellan had kept the Union's morale in tip-top shape, they hadn't been doing to good in the war, especially a huge failed attack to seize Richmond, Virginia. Lincoln did not approve of McClellan, and he was out of the major general position after a brief term (November 1861 to March 1862).Now lets move on to Ulysses S. Grant (18th President of the United States)...As many people know, Grant was the last general Lincoln hired and won the Civil War against Robert E. Lee's stellar South. Unlike McClellan, Grant was an aggressive general and seized key points like Kentucky, Tennessee, and the Mississippi River. Grant was a fast-paced general that was definitely needed for the Civil War. The battle that won it all was when Grant's Union army captured Richmond (the Confederacy capital) in April 1865... the final blow for the Confederate army...So yes, Grant was a very effective general. After a series of different generals, Lincoln had found the perfect one!


What army won the US Civil War battles in the Peninsula Campaign?

Although both the Army of the Potomac and the Army of Northern Virginia suffered heavy casualties, the Peninsula Campaign is considered to be a victory for the Confederacy. The reason for this idea was because McClellan had failed to achieve his primary objective and had to retreat. George McClellan, commanding general of the federal Army of the Potomac, invaded Virginia with the design of capturing Richmond and ending the war. The able manuevering by Robert E. Lee of the Army of Northern Virginia caused McClellan to withdraw, thus easing the pressure on the Confederacy's capital. McClellan's withdraw caused elation in the South and foreboding throughout the North. It cause of great concern to US President Lincoln and he asked General Halleck to assess McClellan's position as he rested his army before finally retreating back to Fort Monroe. Additionally, Halleck came to the conclusion that McClellan had lost of whatever good military judgment he had. Halleck also lost any credibility he may have had regarding McClellan's ability to access the strength of the Confederate army. The Peninsula campaign was nearly a success as at one point Union forces were only six miles from Richmond.


How did the Union's General Orders Number 109 affect the US Civil War?

The failure of General George B. McClellan's Peninsula campaign unsettled many of Lincoln's supporters. In view of no immediate plans that matched the intended level of the campaign to take Richmond via the "peninsula, Lincoln needed to do something to regain some of the lost momentum. The result was General Orders 109. This action reiterated permission to seize property and supplies in Rebel states that could be used as war supplies. It went a bit further however, and did not please everyone. Seizing property allowed for such property to be returned. Lincoln raised the destructive level of the Union's intent to end the rebellion by allowing for the destruction of the aforementioned property. Lincoln also ordered the employment of Blacks as laborers, although, and an important although, to keep good records on this so that compensation to the slave owners might be made in the future.