answersLogoWhite

0

When Romeo tries to kill himself in Act III Scene 3, the Friar talks him out of it. But he does not use the Church's position on suicide to do so. And wisely so. Romeo is in a mood to defy damnation, and the friar well knows that the only way to reach Romeo is to appeal to his love for Juliet. Thus he argues that by killing himself Romeo will also kill Juliet, whose life is entwined with his. He argues that Romeo will make himself a perjurer if he kills the one he has sworn to love. These arguments, plus the argument that there is still hope for life together despite the banishment, are what persuades Romeo to abandon the suicide idea. An argument along the lines of "Don't commit suicide or you will go to Hell." would have had no effect. The closest he comes is by describing suicide as "doing damnéd hate".

There is good reason for this. Romeo and Juliet is a play, not a catechism class. Shakespeare's audience knew exactly what the church's position on suicide was and is, as do most modern readers. Just in case you don't, suicide is a mortal sin in the Catholic Church, and suicides are denied funerals and burial in consecrated ground. We see the effect of this in another Shakespeare play, Hamlet, where Ophelia's burial is compromised because she is a suspected suicide.

User Avatar

Wiki User

8y ago

What else can I help you with?

Related Questions

Does Hartford group life insurance pay out for a suicide death?

From what I could gather... each individual policy is unique. Commonly, there is a period from the purchase date that is a "no-suicide" period. Typically this period is 24 months and after, it seems most people receive compensation in the event of a suicide. However, I did find numerous people that complained about the Hartford Group in particular saying that an event was ruled a suicide, instead of "accidental", and because of this, the Hartford refuses to pay. Hope this helps.


What did actor James kenney die from?

He committed suicide but I don't know by what method. I gather his later life was verysad, having alcohol & drug problems. A terrible waste of a talented life,


How many people committed suicide in the year 2015?

In two years it will be 2015. Then it can take another year to gather all the information to offer the correct numbers. For today, your question is impossible to answer.


What is the present form of gather?

To gather I gather You gather he gathers we gather you (pl) gather they gather I am gathering You are gathering he is gathering we are gathering you (pl) are gathering they are gathering


How can a t chart help your gather evidence that supports your position on a local tax increase?

it will help you organize facts that both support and attack


When a child commits suicide is a autopsy done on the child?

Yes, an autopsy is typically performed on a child who dies by suicide to determine the cause of death and gather evidence. Autopsies can provide crucial information to understand the circumstances surrounding the death and help in the investigation and prevention of future incidents.


How can one effectively triangulate a position?

To effectively triangulate a position, one must gather information from multiple sources, analyze and compare the data, and then use this information to determine a precise location or viewpoint. This process involves cross-referencing different sources to validate and strengthen the accuracy of the position.


Which structure in the ear gathers information about the position of your body?

The vestibular system in the inner ear, specifically the semicircular canals and otolith organs, gather information about the position of your body in space and help maintain balance.


Explain how to gather data quickly and accurately?

How to gather gather data quickly and accurately?


How do you say 'gather' in Japanese?

Atsumaru is 'to gather' in the crowd sense; (To gather around someone) Atsumeru is 'to gather' as in to collect.


Do whales gather into flocks?

No, they gather in Pods.


What does no sanctuary mean?

a place to gather to gather