0
He had a disagreement with Agamemnon over a girl.
Wiki User
∙ 11y ago
Add your answer:
Earn +20 pts
Why did Achilles change his decision not to participate in the war?
Achilles was angry at Agamemnon for taking his war prize - a girl named Briseus, and he wanted to get back at him, so he refused to fight. He also wanted the Greeks to realize they couldn't win a battle without him. He knew that when they came to ask him to return to battle, he would obtain more glory and honor for fighting, because they couldn't do it without him.
What does Nestor tell Telemachus about Agamemnon Menelaus and Odysseus?
Nestor tells Achilles and Agamemnon that it is sad to see the Greeks divided and that they should pay attention to his wise words. He tells Achilles that he should not think he can fight against a king and that Agamemnon is greater than he is because he rules over more people. He then tells Agamemnon that even though he is powerful, he should not take Briseis because the Greeks gave her to Achilles as his prize of honor.
What is historically incorrect about the movie Troy?
The movie showed Brad Pitt (Achilles) as being more of a warrior than Hector was, which was not true. If Hector could hold the combat for many years, then obviously he was more of a match to Achilles. The movie also showed that Achilles was angered when Agamemnon claimed his woman, who happened to be Hector's sister. in the myth, Achilles was angered over the claiming of Briseis who was not royal at all.
What is Achilles' role in the Illiad?
Achilles plays a great role in the Trojan war.When Agamemnon steals the beautiful captive Briseis away from Achilles,Achilles refuses to take part in the war,where after the Greeks suffer one loss after another.But when his best friend Patroclus is killed by Trojan Hector,Achilles emerges vengeful.Thetis has an armor forged for Achilles by the great god Hephaestus.Achilles kills Hector and a great number of other Trojans.Ajax is considered to be the bravest hero,second only to Achilles.In the Trojan war he single-handedly turns back a Trojan counterattack that threatens to set the fleet on fire.ajax and diomedes are considered the second best Greeks next to Achilles, however both of these heroes are more noble, brave and respectful than Achilles. ajax fights hector to duel early in the iliad, and through out the book both heroes try to kill each, both are unsuccesful, though on occassions both heroes get the upper hand on one another, hector forces ajax to retreat several times and also breaks ajax's spear. however ajax also forces hector to retreat on one occasion when he throws a huge boulder at hector. diomedes is also a great fighter but not as good in my opinion as ajax or hector, he always needs the help of odyesseus and like wise odyesseus always needs diomedes's help. ajax and hector fight alone, relying on their own skill. Achilles i would like to point out is not brave, he doesnt fight for most of the iliad, and has no fear of death, that by definition does not define a hero, he doesnt care about anyone or anything expect his feelings and perhaps patroclus.
How does Achilles finally kill Hector?
There was a duel between Hector and Achilles , and Achilles was successful in killing Hector late in the day. it wasnt really a duel, it was an unfair fight, athene helped Achilles overcome hector. Achilles was also wearing god's amour and was fed on ambrosia, Achilles had refused to eat and both Odysseus and Zeus realised that a starved Achilles would be no match for a well fed hector. Achilles killed hector by thrusting his spear into his neck, the only vulnerable spot on hector's body when he was wearing Achilles' armour. both heroes exchanged spear throws, Achilles missed but athene returned his spear, hector did not miss and hit Achilles' shield, however he was tricked by athene who disguised herself as hector's brother deiphoubus holdind another spear for him and then abandoned him. hector then charges Achilles, knowing he is going to die, with his sword and he is likened to a high flying eagle, noble and strong swooping down upon Achilles who is likened to a timid hare. Achilles with athene's help slays his enemy and then proceeds to maltreat hector, this act was deemed disgusting and wrong in homeric times and still today. Zeus grows enfuriated by this as hector was his favourite mortal, aswell as Apollo's and perhaps even ares. Achilles is not the true hero of the iliad and in my view is not even a hero at all. homer intends us to feel great pathos, sympathy, for hector the greatest hero for so many more reasons than just a talented warrior. he is the most noble and brave character in Homer's Iliad.
Was Achilles justified in his wrath against Agamemnon and his subsequent withdrawal from battle?
Yes, Achilles is justified in his wrath against Agamemnon and his subsequent withdrawal from battle. Reasons: Agamemnon is being selfish Agamemnon cares more about Chyrsies than his army Achilles does not have to fight in the war, but he is doing it for Agamemnon
What is learnt about the characters Agamemnon and Achilles in Book 1?
We, as an audience, find out different aspects of each of these character's personalities in Book 1. During the assembly that Achilles calls, he calls for a seer to be summoned to see why Apollo is angry and has sent them the plague, illustrating his desire for things to be put right. Agamemnon is resentful at being told what to do, showing his need to remain in control. Achilles speaks directly to Agamemnon calling him greedy, showing that he has no respect for the King after dishonouring him (Agamemnon has distributed the prizes, that the army has won, unequally, according to Achilles. He is their best fighter and thus demands more rewards than the other fighters, but Agamemnon refuses). Achilles then tells his leader that it would be in their best interests to give back the girl, Chryseis to her father and accept the ransom offered by him. He promises that he and his men will over-reward Agamemnon for this deed, if he would just see it through. Achilles speaks of Gods while referring to this, emphasising the importance of the situation and his deeper respect for them than Agamemnon. Agamemnon refuses to go back on what he has already decided, regarding Chryseis, in fear that it will make him look like a weak leader, but in fact, it would be quite the opposite. Agamemnon gives an insecure speech, but tries too hard maintain his status. He jumps to conclusions, accusing Achilles of tricking him into giving the girl back, so he can keep his own, Briseis, safe. However, this is not strictly true. Achilles proceeds to insult his leader more, calling him self centred and a swine. He tells him that he didn't even want to come to fight as he had no grudge against the Trojans, but only came to gain glory for Agamemnon, as did the rest of their army. He tells him that he has been cheated out of his booty as he does all the fighting and doesn't get any larger reward than the others for his bravery and also Agamemnon takes the most of it for himself. Achilles becomes a little melodramatic and declares that he will return home, leaving the army without his help. Agamemnon replies patronisingly that he should leave, then and can do without him (which he obviously can't). He suddenly leaps to his last resort of trying to maintain a higher status than Achilles, attempting to reprimand him in front of the whole army, declaring that he will take away his prize. But this is showing his desperation as he is not quite in control. Athena intervenes, just when Achilles is about to kill Agamemnon, and instead of killing the King, Achilles proceeds to insult him, emphasising his respect for the Gods. But he pushes his luck with Agamemnon, and tells him that he will regret having hurt his pride and wishes the Greek army to fall by Hector's hand. We learn that Achilles is not afraid to escalate the situation in defending his honour.
Why did Achilles change his decision not to participate in the war?
Achilles was angry at Agamemnon for taking his war prize - a girl named Briseus, and he wanted to get back at him, so he refused to fight. He also wanted the Greeks to realize they couldn't win a battle without him. He knew that when they came to ask him to return to battle, he would obtain more glory and honor for fighting, because they couldn't do it without him.
What does Nestor tell Telemachus about Agamemnon Menelaus and Odysseus?
Nestor tells Achilles and Agamemnon that it is sad to see the Greeks divided and that they should pay attention to his wise words. He tells Achilles that he should not think he can fight against a king and that Agamemnon is greater than he is because he rules over more people. He then tells Agamemnon that even though he is powerful, he should not take Briseis because the Greeks gave her to Achilles as his prize of honor.
He borrowed Achilles armor when Achilles refused to fight?
This was Patroclus, Achilles's cousin
What famous people or myths derive from Greece?
The legends of early Greece appear in the Iliad and Odyssey, including Achilles, Odysseus, Agamemnon, Menelaus plus many more.
What people fought in the Trojan War?
The Trojans, more specifically, Paris, Hector, and all of the Trojan army. Greeks from all around including Agamemnon, Achilles, and Odysseus.
What is historically incorrect about the movie Troy?
The movie showed Brad Pitt (Achilles) as being more of a warrior than Hector was, which was not true. If Hector could hold the combat for many years, then obviously he was more of a match to Achilles. The movie also showed that Achilles was angered when Agamemnon claimed his woman, who happened to be Hector's sister. in the myth, Achilles was angered over the claiming of Briseis who was not royal at all.
Does Achilles really love Briseis?
In the context of the Iliad, Achilles' relationship with Briseis is more about possession and honor rather than love. Achilles values Briseis as a symbolic representation of his status and authority, which is why he reacts so strongly when she is taken from him by Agamemnon. Their relationship is complex and reflects the power dynamics of that society.
Who were the leaders of the two sides in the Trojan war?
Agamemnon - king of Thebes - was commander in chief of the Greek forces. Troy's commander in chief was King Priam, but the army was under the control of his son Hector. What precisely happened to the Trojan command structure after Hector was killed by Achilles is not entirely clear from the stories we have, but Aeneas was in command of the city defenses, and probably took an even more senior role after the death of his commander.
What is Achilles' role in the Illiad?
Achilles plays a great role in the Trojan war.When Agamemnon steals the beautiful captive Briseis away from Achilles,Achilles refuses to take part in the war,where after the Greeks suffer one loss after another.But when his best friend Patroclus is killed by Trojan Hector,Achilles emerges vengeful.Thetis has an armor forged for Achilles by the great god Hephaestus.Achilles kills Hector and a great number of other Trojans.Ajax is considered to be the bravest hero,second only to Achilles.In the Trojan war he single-handedly turns back a Trojan counterattack that threatens to set the fleet on fire.ajax and diomedes are considered the second best Greeks next to Achilles, however both of these heroes are more noble, brave and respectful than Achilles. ajax fights hector to duel early in the iliad, and through out the book both heroes try to kill each, both are unsuccesful, though on occassions both heroes get the upper hand on one another, hector forces ajax to retreat several times and also breaks ajax's spear. however ajax also forces hector to retreat on one occasion when he throws a huge boulder at hector. diomedes is also a great fighter but not as good in my opinion as ajax or hector, he always needs the help of odyesseus and like wise odyesseus always needs diomedes's help. ajax and hector fight alone, relying on their own skill. Achilles i would like to point out is not brave, he doesnt fight for most of the iliad, and has no fear of death, that by definition does not define a hero, he doesnt care about anyone or anything expect his feelings and perhaps patroclus.
Who is more famous Achilles or Sonic the Hedgehog?
Achilles , the Greek hero from the Trojan War .
