Who is older Laney or Haley?

Answer 1

well...in when im gone he says at the end

"haillie just smiles and winks at her LITTLE sister

but in mocking bird one of them has black hair and that's laney and she looks older than haillie. So guessing that when im gone is a future song for kim as if they where going to have another girl. (: i know it dosent make much sense but what im trying to write is that laney is possibly older x

^i agree with most of what you say above but the fact is eminem has adopted kims other daughter Whitney, who would be the 'little sister' hailie is smiling and winking at in 'when im gone' and 'mockingbird' shows that laney must be older, so in age order it goes laney, hailie then Whitney.