answersLogoWhite

0


Want this question answered?

Be notified when an answer is posted

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: What two types of laws conflict in this scene 2 Antigone?
Write your answer...
Submit
Still have questions?
magnify glass
imp
Continue Learning about Performing Arts

What is the conflict between Antigone and Creon in 'Antigone'?

Whom to obey is the conflict between Antigone and Creon in "Antigone" by Sophocles (495 B.C.E. - 405 B.C.E.).Specifically, Theban Princess Antigone believes that the gods rule in life and death. She chooses to obey the gods when divine and royal laws conflict. In contrast, her uncle King Creon expects his own laws to be obeyed.


What is the conflict of 'Antigone'?

The conflict of 'Antigone' is the conflict between the manmade laws of the State and the god-given laws of justice; morality; and rites, rituals, and traditions. The laws of the State are represented by Theban King Creon's decree that the disloyal Theban dead are to be left above ground and exposed to the elements, dogs, and birds. This is in direct opposition to the traditions of the preparation of the dead for their passage into the realms of the underworld god. Antigone respects the living and the dead. But she can't respect a law that violates the basic rules by which Thebans live. And so Antigone represents the timeless, god-given laws of a higher moralityabove and beyond those laws enacted by mortals.


What flaw in Antigone does the chorus point out?

The flaw in Antigone that the chorus pointed out to her in Scene 4, line 45 was her lack of respect for human laws. This flaw would lead to her death, and the chorus blamed Antigone for her own demise.


What is the conflict between Antigone and Ismene in 'Antigone'?

Whom to obey is the conflict between Antigone and Ismene in "Antigone" by Sophocles (495 B.C.E. - 405 B.C.E.).Specifically, Theban Princess Antigone considers divine will the ultimate in law and the gods the ultimate in authority figures. In contrast, her sister Princess Ismene looks to the more immediate authority of their uncle King Creon and his laws. She understandably shudders at the thought of confronting her daunting uncle and his equally daunting death sentences to violators of his laws.


What is the basic conflict in 'Antigone'?

Who is the ultimate authority to be respected in life is the basic conflict in "Antigone" by Sophocles (495 B.C.E. - 405 B.C.E.).Specifically, Theban King Creon says that he is the ultimate authority in Thebes. Princess Antigone says that the gods always are the ultimate authority, in Thebes and in the Underworld of the afterlife. It turns into quite a conflict once it becomes not only a question of beliefs to defend but also laws to obey.

Related questions

What is the conflict between Antigone and Creon in 'Antigone'?

Whom to obey is the conflict between Antigone and Creon in "Antigone" by Sophocles (495 B.C.E. - 405 B.C.E.).Specifically, Theban Princess Antigone believes that the gods rule in life and death. She chooses to obey the gods when divine and royal laws conflict. In contrast, her uncle King Creon expects his own laws to be obeyed.


What is the conflict of 'Antigone'?

The conflict of 'Antigone' is the conflict between the manmade laws of the State and the god-given laws of justice; morality; and rites, rituals, and traditions. The laws of the State are represented by Theban King Creon's decree that the disloyal Theban dead are to be left above ground and exposed to the elements, dogs, and birds. This is in direct opposition to the traditions of the preparation of the dead for their passage into the realms of the underworld god. Antigone respects the living and the dead. But she can't respect a law that violates the basic rules by which Thebans live. And so Antigone represents the timeless, god-given laws of a higher moralityabove and beyond those laws enacted by mortals.


What flaw in Antigone does the chorus point out?

The flaw in Antigone that the chorus pointed out to her in Scene 4, line 45 was her lack of respect for human laws. This flaw would lead to her death, and the chorus blamed Antigone for her own demise.


What is the conflict between Antigone and Ismene in 'Antigone'?

Whom to obey is the conflict between Antigone and Ismene in "Antigone" by Sophocles (495 B.C.E. - 405 B.C.E.).Specifically, Theban Princess Antigone considers divine will the ultimate in law and the gods the ultimate in authority figures. In contrast, her sister Princess Ismene looks to the more immediate authority of their uncle King Creon and his laws. She understandably shudders at the thought of confronting her daunting uncle and his equally daunting death sentences to violators of his laws.


What is the basic conflict in 'Antigone'?

Who is the ultimate authority to be respected in life is the basic conflict in "Antigone" by Sophocles (495 B.C.E. - 405 B.C.E.).Specifically, Theban King Creon says that he is the ultimate authority in Thebes. Princess Antigone says that the gods always are the ultimate authority, in Thebes and in the Underworld of the afterlife. It turns into quite a conflict once it becomes not only a question of beliefs to defend but also laws to obey.


What is Antigone's principal argument with Creon?

The conflict between Antigone and Creon was over which laws to respect. Antigone believed that some laws came from the gods. Such laws, such as the rites and rituals for proper burial, must be respected. In contrast, Theban King Creon believed that all lawmaking fell generally within the human domain, and most specifically within his powers as ruler of Thebes.


What are the opposing forces for each conflict in 'Antigone'?

Antigone and Ismene, Antigone and Creon, Creon and Haemon, and Creon and Teiresias are the opposing forces in the conflicts in "Antigone" by Sophocles (495 B.C.E. - 405 B.C.E.).Specifically, Theban Princesses Antigone and Ismene are on opposing sides in the conflict over whether or not to bury their brother Polyneices and whether to obey divine or human law. Antigone and King Creon also are on opposite sides in that conflict even though they both agree that Antigone will die. Creon opposes his son Haemon and then his advisor, Teiresias the blind prophet, on just about everything: burial versus non-burial, divine versus human laws, release or sentencing of Antigone.


Is a theme of 'Antigone' the conflict between the man made laws and the divine laws?

Yes, one of the themes in 'Antigone' is the conflict between man made and divine laws. Antigone represents respect for god given traditions, rituals and rites. For example, the people of her city are guaranteed proper burial rites and rituals, because of being Thebans and because of the power and wisdom of the gods. In contrast, Antigone's uncle, Theban King Creon, represents a godless rule of mortals. For example, Creon doesn't believe that god given traditions, rituals and rites need to be carved any longer in stone. They can be changed or disregarded, at will. And that precisely is where the conflict begins, with Antigone refusing to discard what always has been there and with Creon thinking that he can be the one to make unprecedented changes.


What is the minor conflict in 'Antigone'?

Whether or not to obey the royal edict is the minor conflict in "Antigone" by Sophocles (495 B.C.E. - 405 B.C.E.).Specifically, the phrase minor conflict describes a disagreement that does not involve both main characters but that relates to their main conflict. The description fits the opening disagreement between the Theban sister Princesses Antigone and Ismene. Antigone insists that their brother Polyneices must be buried and that the royal edict of non-burial therefore must be disobeyed. In contrast, Ismene maintains that the laws of the city must not be broken. The disagreement relates to the major conflict between the main characters, Antigone and Creon, over the ultimate authority figures in life and death.


What is the main conflict faced by Antigone in the opening scene of 'Antigone'?

Which of two conflicting laws to obeyis the main conflict that Antigone faces as the play opens in "Antigone" by Sophocles (495 B.C.E. -- 405 B.C.E.).Specifically, Theban Princess Antigone learns that the divinely guaranteed rights of all Thebans to below-ground burials and funeral rites are to become privileges to be respected for some and denied to others. One person who is to be left above ground and exposed to the ravages of the weather and wildlife is her brother Polyneices. She must resolve whether to disobey King Creon's edict, bury Polyneices and be sentenced to death or to disobey divine will, buck Theban traditions, not bury Polyneices and face consequences for all time in the Underworld of the afterlife.


What is Antigone's attitude toward the laws of Thebes in 'Antigone'?

That at least one of them is illegal is Antigone's attitude toward the laws of Thebes in "Antigone" by Sophocles (495 B.C.E. - 405 B.C.E.).Specifically, Theban Princess Antigone does not accept a conflict between a royal edict and divinely ordained Theban traditions. She expresses strongly supportive feelings for her family and the gods. It is not easy to understand her position regarding royals other than that their actions must be in line with divine will and that King Creon's non-burial edict does not do so.


What is a fair and just society in 'Antigone'?

A society in which there is no conflict between its laws and divine justice is a fair and just society in "Antigone" by Sophocles (495 B.C.E. - 405 B.C.E.).Specifically, the definition appears in the first choral ode. It is found in the ending lines, just before the beginning of the second scene. The chorus refers to the necessary mesh between what the gods consider punishable and non-punishable and what the city defines as right and wrong under the law.