answersLogoWhite

0


Best Answer

Malcolm tells this to Macduff as a test to see if he, Macduff, is really loyal to Scotland or if he is there by request of Macbeth to retrieve Malcolm so Macbeth could kill him. This takes place when Macduff if trying to reclaim the crown of Scotland from Macbeth by force and put the rightful heir into throne. Before Macduff, many others had come to try and bring Malcolm back (or it is implied at least), so that is why Malcolm does not trust Macduff so he, like i said, tested him and his loyalty to Scotland

User Avatar

Wiki User

14y ago
This answer is:
User Avatar
More answers
User Avatar

Wiki User

11y ago

It's a kind of a test. Malcolm describes himself as a horrible monster in order to see whether Macduff is really a spy from Macbeth. It's kind of stupid because if Malcolm really were as awful as he says he is, he wouldn't go around telling everyone. If Macduff really were a spy he'd see right through it, but he's not, and all he sees is that he has gone to all the trouble to seek this guy out only to find that he's bragging that he's just as bad as Macbeth.

This answer is:
User Avatar

User Avatar

Wiki User

11y ago

Malcolm tells Macduff that he is worse than Macbeth in every possible way, in order to test him, apparently.

This answer is:
User Avatar

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: Why does Malcolm tell Macduff that he shouldn't rule Scotland?
Write your answer...
Submit
Still have questions?
magnify glass
imp
Continue Learning about Performing Arts

How does Macbeth handle the threat posed by Macduff?

Malcom tests Macduff by saying he is going to be a horrible king. He says that this is a test to see if Macduff will continue to support him even if he was worse than Macbeth. If Macduff said he would then Malcolm would know him for a toady who would agree to anything. He then claims to be well-nigh perfect, and that he has never told a lie before the whopper he just told to Macduff. Yeah, right. Anyway, Macduff is prepared to go along with him because he would do anything to get rid of Macbeth.


Who became king of scotland after macbeth's death?

In the Shakespearean play, King Duncan I [d. August 14, 1040] was stabbed to death by Macbeth [c. 1014-August 15, 1057]. Macbeth then was King for 17 years. He was killed and beheaded by Macduff, who sought revenge for the loss of his entire family and household. But the Scotsman who replaced Macbeth on Scotland's throne was King Duncan I's elder son, King Malcolm III [d. November 13, 1093]. The version of the royal succession by William Shakespeare [Baptized April 26, 1564-April 23, 1616] wasn't backed up by the historical record. Instead, King Duncan was killed by his own men for having launched an unprovoked, unpopular, unjustified, unjust invasion of Macbeth's lands in Moray. After 17 years of rule, Macbeth was succeeded by his stepson, King Lulach [d. March 17, 1058]. King Lulach in turn was succeeded by King Malcolm III, King Duncan's elder son and the murderer of Kings Macbeth and Lulach.


Why is Macbeth compelled to kill people in the play?

Macbeth resorted to murder, to consolidate his power and thereby to satisfy his ambitions. He killed his sovereign, King Duncan, to rule Scotland. He killed the royal guards, to blame them for King Duncan's murder and to keep them from being potential witnesses against him. He killed his best friend, Banquo, whose family line was prophesied as inheriting the throne. He killed Macduff's family, because the witches had warned him to beware of Macduff. He killed Young Siward, and countless others, because he could.


How did the doctor attending Lady Macbeth provide a contrast to the King of England in Act 5?

The contrast was between the Doctor's inaction and the King's action. In Act 5 Scene 1, the Doctor let the Gentlewoman attendant persuade him to witness the odd behavior of Lady Macbeth [b. c. 1015]. He traced the cause of the Lady's hand rubbing, sleepwalking, and talking to herself to emotional and mental problems within herself. Then in Scene 3, he discussed these problems with her husband, Macbeth [c. 1014-August 15, 1057]. In both scenes, his conclusions were his inability to solve the problems and the patient's need to cure herself. This reaction directly contrasted with the reactions of King Edward the Confessor [c. 1003-January 5, 1066] of England. In Act 2 Scene 2, the future King Malcolm III [d. November 13, 1093] fled Scotland for the English court. In Act 4 Scene 3, he was joined by Macduff near one of the English King's palaces. At first, Malcolm and Macduff talked about the suffering of Scotland under Macbeth's rule. Then they switched to the English people's suffering from scrofula. As with Macbeth's Lady, the English sufferers were blamed for inner causes of outward suffering. But unlike the Lady's Doctor, King Edward was proactive and made healing interventions. Likewise was the English King proactive in regard to the suffering of Scotland. In fact, Malcolm told Macduff that his Uncle Siward, Earl of Northumberland and General of the English Army, was being allowed to get together a 10,000 soldier strong force against Macbeth. In Act 5 Scene 2, the combined forces of invading Englishmen and discontented Scotsmen already were near Macbeth's royal castle of Dunsinane and even nearer to Birnam Wood. The scene showed the English King's proactiveness in seeing a problem and stepping in to solve it. The proactiveness provided especially effective contrast by being sandwiched between Scenes 1 and 3, in which the Doctor saw his royal patient's problem and did nothing.


What happened to Lady Macbeth in Act 5?

The witches promised Macbeth that Dunsinane Castle would never fall until the Forest of Birnam attacked it. Malcolm's army uses brushwood from Birnam Forest as camouflage - so that part of the prophecy is fulfilled. The witches also promise Macbeth that no man born of woman can kill him. Macduff was born by Caesarian section, after the death of his mother - so technically he was not born of a woman, but of a corpse. You just can't trust these witches - though they do tell him to beware of Macduff (that part was good advice).

Related questions

How does Macduff respond to each of Malcolm's three confessions in the Shakespearean play Macbeth?

Macduff didn't abandon Malcolm's cause but instead grieved for his country. Malcolm then revealed his intention to restore just rule to Scotland.


What do Malcolm and mcduff now call Macbeth?

Malcolm and Macduff now refer to Macbeth as a "tyrant" for his cruel and oppressive rule as king of Scotland.


What do malcom and macduff have in common?

Malcolm and Macduff are both key characters in Shakespeare's play "Macbeth." They share a common goal of overthrowing Macbeth and restoring rightful rule to Scotland. Both characters are also deeply affected by the actions and consequences of Macbeth's reign.


Why might Macduff in particular be keen to seek Macbeth's death?

Macduff is keen to seek Macbeth's death because Macbeth has murdered his family, including his wife and children. Macduff sees it as his duty to seek revenge and rid Scotland of Macbeth's tyrannical rule. Additionally, Macduff is loyal to the rightful king, Malcolm, and believes that Macbeth's death is necessary to restore order and justice to the kingdom.


Which characters organize to fight Macbeth at the end of the play?

At the end of the play, Macduff, Malcolm, Siward, and other Scottish nobles organize to fight against Macbeth and his forces. They seek to overthrow Macbeth's tyrannical rule and restore rightful order to Scotland.


What do ross and macduff decide to do at the end of scene 4?

In Act 5, Scene 4 of Shakespeare's play "Macbeth," Ross and Macduff decide to join forces with Malcolm and the English army to overthrow Macbeth and restore order to Scotland. They are determined to rid the country of Macbeth's tyrannical rule and bring about a new era of peace and prosperity under Malcolm's leadership.


What is the effect of killying macduff's family?

Killing Macduff's family causes Macduff to become more determined to seek revenge on Macbeth, as it increases his personal vendetta against him. This act also leads Macduff to join forces with Malcolm and the English army to overthrow Macbeth's tyrannical rule.


Where is macduff during act 3 and why?

Macduff is in England during Act 3. He has gone there to seek help from King Edward of England to overthrow Macbeth and restore rightful rule to Scotland.


What nation's army invades Scotland at the end of Macbeth?

The English army, led by Malcolm and Siward, invades Scotland at the end of Macbeth to overthrow Macbeth's tyrannical rule and restore Malcolm as the rightful king.


How does Macbeth handle the threat posed by Macduff?

Malcom tests Macduff by saying he is going to be a horrible king. He says that this is a test to see if Macduff will continue to support him even if he was worse than Macbeth. If Macduff said he would then Malcolm would know him for a toady who would agree to anything. He then claims to be well-nigh perfect, and that he has never told a lie before the whopper he just told to Macduff. Yeah, right. Anyway, Macduff is prepared to go along with him because he would do anything to get rid of Macbeth.


What happened before Macbeth could be vanquished?

Before Macbeth could be vanquished, he faced a final battle against the forces opposing him led by Malcolm, the rightful heir to the throne. During the battle, Macbeth was ultimately killed by Macduff, ending his tyrannical rule over Scotland.


Why does macduff go to see Malcolm?

Macduff goes to see Malcolm in order to persuade him to lead an army against Macbeth. Macduff seeks Malcolm's help as he views him as a legitimate heir to the throne and believes that together they can overthrow Macbeth's tyrannical rule.