answersLogoWhite

0

For something to be morally good (in the words of Kant), you must be able to universalize the maxim (have it be something everyone wills/wants). Which is pretty much the golden rule. The difference is that Kant says three things must be possible for it to be good.

1: Formulate the maxim- "I will do it"

2: Universalize the maxin - Everyone may/everyone will do it as well

3: Ask if you can will 1 & 2 at the same time w/o defeating the maxim

One example on how the golden rule differs is:

Someone asks for a loan even when they know they cannot pay for it, but they promise to do so.

Kant:

1- Possible

2- Possible (everyone can do it)

3- Impossible, the goal was to get the loan, but if everyone promised to pay the money back when they knew they couldn't, promises would no longer exist because no one would accept them. Therefore the goal is not reached.

Golden Rule:

You would not want someone to do that do you, therefore you wouldn't do it

So they both agree that it is not morally good, but in different manners. I hope this helps, if you have any more questions email me: ivins@wisc.edu

User Avatar

Wiki User

∙ 17y ago
User Avatar

What else can I help you with?

Related Questions

What is Atticus belief in the golden rule?

Atticus believes in treating others with respect and empathy, following the principle of the golden rule: treating others as you would like to be treated. He teaches his children to understand different perspectives and to approach situations with kindness and understanding. He believes in the importance of morality, justice, and equality for all individuals.


Who invented the king Midas and the golden touch?

It is a morality tale from ancient Greek mythology - original author unknown.


What is the principle of the golden mean?

The principle of the golden mean, also known as the golden ratio, is a mathematical ratio of 1:1.618 that is considered visually pleasing. In design and aesthetics, adhering to this ratio is believed to create a sense of balance and harmony. It is often found in nature, art, and architecture.


What is golden rule by kant?

The Golden Rule of Do unto others as you would have them do unto you is seen by Immanuel Kant as missing an element of what the person really wants and needs due to the situation. In general, what is now called the Platinum Rule has more of what he believed was important. That is, "Treat others the way they want to be treated."


What is Hans gross's golden rule?

Hans Gross's Golden Rule is a principle in criminal investigation that emphasizes the importance of securing the crime scene to preserve evidence and prevent contamination. It states, "Locard's Exchange Principle" which suggests that every contact leaves a trace. This principle highlights the significance of maintaining the integrity of the crime scene to ensure accurate investigation outcomes.


The Golden Mean principle suggests that a good general guide to living virtuously is to?

seek moderation and avoid excess


What principle did Confucius strongly promote?

Confucius (551-479 BC) was a teacher, editor, politician and philosopher in China. The principle he promoted most was his Golden Rule, " Do not do to others what you do not want done to yourself."


What is humanism golden rule?

The humanist golden rule is the idea that one should treat others as they would like to be treated themselves. This principle emphasizes empathy, compassion, and respect for the dignity and worth of every individual.


Aristotle taught his students to follow the what?

Aristotle taught his students to follow the principle of moderation or the "golden mean." This concept suggests finding a balance between extremes in behavior or emotions to achieve virtue and lead a harmonious life.


How many golden tickets are there in each state?

The number of golden tickets varies by state and is not fixed. In the context of the "Willy Wonka & the Chocolate Factory" story, there are five golden tickets hidden in chocolate bars worldwide, not distributed by state. In real-life promotions or events, the number of golden tickets can differ depending on the specific campaign or contest rules.


What principle did Confucius most strongly promote?

Confucius (551-479 BC) was a teacher, editor, politician and philosopher in China. The principle he promoted most was his Golden Rule, " Do not do to others what you do not want done to yourself."


Why is the golden rule so important?

surely because its one of the most fundamental ideas surrounding christianity? calling it the 'golden rule' just emphasises the fact

Trending Questions
Who were the philosophers and what did they want to accomplish? Can you give me a moral lessons about tungkung langit and alunsina? 9. The is the idea image or feeling associated with a word that is different from its actual meaning. A. argument B. denotation C. connotation D. word choice? Can aluminum foil effectively protect credit cards from electronic theft? How a support network of people who are skilled critical thinkers can enhance your ability not to use or fall for faulty reasoning? What significance does the symbol of the Jesus cross hold in real life and how does it impact individuals' beliefs and practices? Does high heat shrink clothes? Who came up with the name smsoh? What is the significance of "he who jumps into the void" and how does it relate to taking risks and embracing the unknown? What of these reason plantation owners preferred to have slaves rather than indentured servants? What is the moral values in the Philippines? Who was the students of Aristotle? What is the difference between morality and ethics, and how do they influence decision-making in various situations? What is the Shangri-La Diet and how does it work to promote weight loss and overall well-being? What is the meaning of educating the mind without educating the heart is no education at all? What is the difference between External and Internal freedom? What was Plato's favourite subject? How should an affirmative conclusion always be worded? Can you define normative philosophy and explain its significance in the field of ethics? Why does eurylochus prove to be a more persuasive leader in this episode than odysseus?