Interpreting the narrator as mentally insane is a common analysis in some works of literature due to their erratic behavior or unreliable narration. It can add depth to the exploration of themes such as perception, reality, and the human condition. However, it's important to consider various interpretations and perspectives when analyzing the narrator's mental state in a poem.
Their defense attorney's claim they don't. Psychiatrists testifying for the prosecution and the defense will argue their own viewpoints.
No. Quite the contrary in fact - which promotes the reader to suspect that the narrator is insane.
The Tell-Tale Heart begins with the narrator insisting that they are not insane despite their meticulous planning to murder an old man who they claim has an evil eye. The narrator's obsession with the old man's eye drives them to commit the crime.
Fear
AnswerHe was not mentally handicapped in any way, he just had a very right-wing perspective which, during his years living on the streets, matured into full-blown xenophobia and hatred of Jews and other ethnic minorities.
he's sane.
well, do you want the serious answer, or the version I've heard... seriously, the stats are impossible for me to find!!! what is up with that? now, as my take on it would be, it appears that people who claim to have seen aliens or UFOs aren't being kept in insane asylums, which accounts for the lack of information... instead, they are being filtered into our secondary schooling system to make druggies appear normal. it's the way our government is trying to hide just how screwed up our nation really is! ;-) back on subject, I'm still trying to find out the actual statistics and will hopefully get back to you soon =]
As I understand it this claim (that he was declared mentally unfit for military service) is unsubstantiated.
The best evidence to support the claim that Montresor is insane is his meticulous planning and execution of Fortunato's murder without showing any remorse or guilt. Additionally, his enjoyment of inflicting pain and suffering on Fortunato further indicates his mental instability. Finally, his delusional belief that the murder was justified and necessary demonstrates a clear disconnect from reality.
Not necessarily. While repetition can reinforce a point, the reliability of a narrator is determined by other factors such as evidence, credibility, consistency, and objectivity in presenting information.
Probably because he is demonstrably insane. No one else hears what he hears. His obsession with killing the old man is also evidence of his insanity. As someone who is not in touch with reality, what he has to say is therefore of dubious reliability.
No, she cannot, without a court order specifically stating that she can. "Mentally abused" is really easy to claim, and really hard to prove. So don't expect to be able to get such a court order.