answersLogoWhite

0

AnswerThe synoptic gospels say that no one of Jesus'acquaintance was at the crucifixion, and that Mary and others watched from afar off. Since no one of Jesus' acquaintance was at the crucifixion, neither Thomas nor Mary could have been.

On the other hand, John's Gospel says that Mary and the 'disciple whom Jesus loved' were at the foot of the cross when Jesus was crucified. We do not know who the disciple was, but the second-century Church Fathers believed him to be the apostle John, a tradition that has followed ever since. The 'disciple whom Jesus loved' is in any case unlikely to be Thomas, because Elaine Pagels detects a thread of anti-Thomas rhetoric throughout John's Gospel, making it unlikely that the author would use this phrase when speaking of Thomas.

So, in John's Gospel, Mary was at the crucifixion with an unnamed disciple who is most unlikely to have been Thomas.

User Avatar

Wiki User

14y ago

What else can I help you with?

Related Questions

What apostale stayed with Mary at the crucifixion?

The apostle John was the only apostle who stayed with Mary, the mother of Jesus, at the foot of the cross during the crucifixion.


Who was the only apostle at Jesus' cross?

John was the only apostle at the cross when he died.


What disciple was with Mary when Jesus was on the cross?

It's generally thought that the Apostle John was at the crucifixion, along with several women including Jesus' mother Mary.AnswerScripture tells us that John was the only disciple to be present at the crucifixion. Jesus spoke to him from the cross to ask him to look after his mother Mary after his death.


Who was the saint who stood with Mary at the foot of the cross?

The saint who stood with Mary at the foot of the cross was St. John the Apostle. He is often referred to as "the disciple whom Jesus loved" and was entrusted by Jesus to care for his mother, Mary, as he died on the cross.


Was Mary at mt calvary with Jesus?

Yes, Mary, the mother of Jesus was there and also another woman named Mary. The apostle John was there too.Yes, Mary, the mother of Jesus was there and also another woman named Mary. The apostle John was there too.Yes, Mary, the mother of Jesus was there and also another woman named Mary. The apostle John was there too.Yes, Mary, the mother of Jesus was there and also another woman named Mary. The apostle John was there too.Yes, Mary, the mother of Jesus was there and also another woman named Mary. The apostle John was there too.Yes, Mary, the mother of Jesus was there and also another woman named Mary. The apostle John was there too.Yes, Mary, the mother of Jesus was there and also another woman named Mary. The apostle John was there too.Yes, Mary, the mother of Jesus was there and also another woman named Mary. The apostle John was there too.Yes, Mary, the mother of Jesus was there and also another woman named Mary. The apostle John was there too.


Who was at the last supper and foot of cross?

The apostles and Jesus were at the Last Supper of Jesus. When Jesus was on the cross, Jesus' mother Mary, the apostle John, and a few other women were there.


Who was the apostle that stayed with Jesus until he died?

The apostle who stayed with Jesus until his death was John, often referred to as the "Beloved Disciple." According to the Gospel of John, he was present at the crucifixion and was entrusted by Jesus with the care of Mary, Jesus' mother. John's unwavering support during Jesus' final moments highlights his close relationship with the Savior.


Who were with Mother Mary when Jesus was being persecuted?

Apostle John, Mary Magdelene and Mary of Cleophas were with Mary during the crucifixion.


Who was the apostle that stayed at the foot of the cross with Jesus?

The Gospels of Matthew, Mark and Luke are clear in saying that no disciple of Jesus stood at the foot of the cross; those of his acquaintance stood afar off. In the Gospel of John, the "disciple whom Jesus loved" stood at the foot of the cross with Mary. Who the disciple was, or who he was intended to be, is unknown. The second-century Church Fathers, by a process of elimination, decided that the disciple must have been John.


Did Apostle Paul and Apostle John cross paths?

Yes. Galatians 2:9


Who was the apostle with Jesus at the cross?

John the Beloved.


Did Mary ever go to Patmos?

No, John the Apostle did.